The dispute

Africa: the UN votes to ‘correct’ geographical maps, infuriating the US

The assembly has given the go-ahead to a resolution to revise the Mercator-era maps and reflect the continent’s actual dimensions

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

NAIROBI – On 4 September, the UN General Assembly gave the go-ahead to a resolution to ‘correct’ world maps and depict the size of Africa more accurately, as it is currently underrepresented in the old Mercator projection.

The text, entitled ‘Correct the Map’, was tabled by the Togolese government on behalf of the African Group at the UN and received 164 votes in favour, six abstentions (Estonia, Georgia, Lithuania, Moldova, Serbia, Ukraine) and a single ‘no’ vote: that of the United States, which was furious at a text accused of ‘ridiculing’ the institution.

Loading...

“Instead of focusing on real issues of international peace, prosperity or good relations,” stated the US Mission, “this body is debating 16th-century cartographic maps and their role in promoting compensation for historical wrongs.” Washington’s reference is to yet another UN resolution calling for recognition of and compensation for damages arising from the slave trade, once again opposed by the United States.

The ‘distortion’ of Africa

The dispute is a long-standing one, but the debate has gathered pace in recent years. The battle for a map update has resulted in a petition on Change.org against the ‘distortions’ in the maps and in favour of a more ‘fair’ representation of sizes, launched in early 2025 and which has now surpassed 12,000 signatures. The African Union, the organisation comprising 55 countries on the continent, endorsed the cause in August of that same year and called on the Togolese government to take the lead in adopting the text that had just been approved in New York.

The projection created in 1569 by Gerardus Mercator, the Flemish mathematician after whom the map is named, is criticised for making Africa appear – significantly – smaller and for exaggerating the size of other regions. This distortion stems from the difficulty of accurately representing the globe on a two-dimensional map and the resulting compromises. Mercator’s map adapts to the curvature of the Earth and remains a standard for maritime navigation, but it has the effect of making countries near the equator appear smaller and those near the poles appear larger.

One of the most frequently cited examples is the disparity between Greenland and Africa, which cover 2.165 million square kilometres and 30.37 million square kilometres respectively. ‘If you look at the Mercator projection,’ reads the Change petition, ‘you’ll probably think that Africa is as big as Greenland [...]. In reality, it is 14 times larger.’

The approved text is not binding, but its aim is to promote ‘cartographic representations which, depending on their intended use, reflect continental dimensions and geographical realities more accurately’. One of the solutions advocated is the Equal Earth map projection, developed in 2018 and considered to be more faithful to the relative sizes of Africa and other geographical regions currently under-represented, such as South America and India.

Dussey (Togo): maps are never neutral

The African Union and Togo, meanwhile, are calling for a more structural outcome: the recognition of a ‘distortion’ that skews the continent’s political and geographical weight. ‘‘This initiative underlines the importance of representing Africa on the basis of objective and scientifically grounded realities,’ said Mahmoud Ali Youssouf, Chairperson of the African Union Commission, in a statement. Robert Dussey, Togolese Foreign Minister and political philosopher, had already clarified the principle before the vote: ‘A map is never neutral,’ said Dussey. ‘It shapes perceptions, influences the way in which the place of peoples and continents in the world is understood, and can, sometimes from the earliest years of schooling, perpetuate representations that do not correspond to geographical reality.’

Copyright reserved ©
  • Alberto Magnani

    Alberto MagnaniCorrispondente

    Luogo: Nairobi

    Lingue parlate: inglese, tedesco

    Argomenti: Lavoro, Unione europea, Africa

    Premi: Premio "Alimentiamo il nostro futuro, nutriamo il mondo. Verso Expo 2015" di Agrofarma Federchimica e Fondazione Veronesi; Premio giornalistico State Street, categoria "Innovation"

Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti