Agnelli inheritance: preliminary hearing judge rejects Elkann’s defence: ‘Evidence from computers and smartphones is admissible’
Elkann’s lawyers, we’re not happy – we’re preparing to take this up
There were no surprises at the preliminary hearing concerning the Agnelli inheritance, where Judge Irene Giani rejected the request by John Elkann’s defence team to have the documents obtained via smartphones and computers by the Turin Public Prosecutor’s Office declared ‘inadmissible’. This was the main issue during the fourth preliminary hearing, which has just concluded at the court in Turin, as part of the investigation into the residence of Marella Caracciolo – widow of the lawyer Gianni Agnelli – during the final years of her life. The investigation into Donna Marella’s estate originated from a complaint lodged by her daughter Margherita Agnelli (John’s mother) regarding her mother’s place of residence. The proceedings concern Elkann, the accountant Gianluca Ferrero and the notary Remo Morone. At the heart of the allegations, on various counts, are claims of fraud against the State and false tax returns. The case will return to court on 4 December.
Elkann’s legal team, we’re not happy – we’re preparing a response
‘Clearly, we are not pleased that the objections have been rejected, but we remain firmly convinced of the points we raised’ and, therefore, ‘they can be raised again at later stages of the proceedings’. Speaking as he left the court, lawyer Paolo Siniscalchi, a member of John Elkann’s defence team, commented on the decision by the preliminary hearing judge to reject the points raised by the defence (including the request to render ‘inadmissible’ the documents obtained via smartphones and computers by the Turin Public Prosecutor’s Office). ‘We firmly believe in them and, therefore, should they be upheld at a later stage, this could even lead to a reversal of the proceedings.’
When asked about a possible decision regarding the request for an expedited trial, ‘the next hearing is on 4 December, and at the moment we are preparing for and organising our case’, the lawyer concluded.

