The knot of secrecy

Weapons from Italy to Ukraine: what we know so far (and what we might know)

Defence Minister Crosetto: 'Hypothesis of secret review on Ukraine arms shipment'

Borrell: "Pensiamo a togliere restrizioni a uso di armi di Kiev"

6' min read

6' min read

Defence Minister Guido Crosetto, speaking at Question Time in the Chamber of Deputies on Wednesday 29 May, opened a window of opportunity. On the subject of the arms that Italy has sent and intends to send to Ukraine, he confided: 'I'm thinking of doing as some nations do, which have not secreted it all but part of it. I'm thinking of going so far as to change those rules that, perhaps mistakenly, you have set and to which I have strictly adhered'. Crosetto thus responded to a question from M5S. "All the things you asked me," Crosetto told MP Francesco Silvestri, "you know them because I answered you at Copasir. You have the list of materials, the caveats and everything but you, like me, are bound by secrecy and cannot speak".

The question is precisely this. Aftertwo years and three months since the invasion of Ukraine, at a time when within the Atlantic Alliance, and in the dialogue between it and its great ally the USA, there are questions about the advisability of giving Kiev the green light to strike with weapons that have been sent to it targets in Russia - with Moscow accusing NATO of dragging the world towards total war and has already alerted the nuclear forces - the fact that in Italy there is a system that does not in fact make this information public is undoubtedly a missing piece in the reconstruction of the complex puzzle that is the crisis in Ukraine. Hence Crosetto's openness, not least because the issue of arms to Ukraine, already at the centre of the political confrontation, has become a key topic in view of the European elections on 8 and 9 June.

Loading...

Copasir and the confidentiality of hearing contents

On 15 October, the Defence Minister was heard at Copasir. In all likelihood, the focus of the speech was the new decree - the nono, after the last one last December - of military aid to be sent to Ukraine. The list of equipment that Italy is preparing to send is also this time secret. And also this time nothing has been leaked. The members of the Parliamentary Committee for the Security of the Republic, as Crosetto himself pointed out, are in fact bound to confidentiality on the contents of the hearings. The Copasir, moreover, is at the centre of a dispute triggered by the Green Left Alliance group, which has requested, in a letter sent to the presidents of the House and Senate, to have its own component in the parliamentary body. By law, in fact, the committee is composed of five members of the majority and five of the opposition, which also has a chairman (the Dem Lorenzo Guerini). The transfer of new weapons to Ukraine, is the position expressed by Avs, makes it advisable to change the composition of the Committee.

NATO and Ukraine ask Italy for new weapons to stem the Russian advance

.

Crosetto has repeatedly stressed that almost everything that could be given has been given. In spite of this, also in the wake of the request for a further effort made by the other NATO countries of Ukraine, Italy is evaluating new weapons that could be sent to Kiev. At the top of the (pressing) demands are air defence systems. Italy has its Samp-t, but must reckon with the need not to leave national defence uncovered, with the G7 underway and the Jubilee advancing.

I Samp-t

There are five Samp-t batteries supplied to Italy, plus one for training. The government already provided Kiev with one last year, in cooperation with France. The Ukrainian military trained in Italy and France in the use of the system. One of the anti-missile systems supplied to Rome returned from Slovakia, after the end of its engagement in the NATO mission Ehanched vigilance activity. Crosetto explained that the return is also linked to the need to increase airspace security during the G7 and the Jubilee. Another battery is deployed in Kuwait, as part of Operation Inherent Resholve. Then there are those engaged for national defence. And the assessment to be made is precisely on how not to deploy them in the event of a positive response to Zelensky's requests. Thoughts are being made together with France and other allies to possibly seek synergies. The Samp-t - which is very expensive - is built by the Italian-French Eurosam consortium, formed by Mbda and Thales. The latest Defence Planning Document states that 1.142 billion have been allocated for these systems for 2024 and 2025. Crosetto pointed out the excessively long delivery times.

Sending means since the outbreak of war

.

Since the first weeks of the conflict in Ukraine (March 2022), Italy has provided military means, materials and equipment to Kiev through a series of measures, taken first by the Draghi government (the fifth package was given the green light by the executive when it was resigning) and then, in February 2023, by Meloni's. In the first decrees, all of which were secret, according to the rumours that have emerged, protective equipment such as helmets and vests, ammunition of different calibre, anti-tank (Panzerfaust) and anti-aircraft (Stinger) systems, mortars, rocket launchers (Milan), light and heavy machine guns (MG 42/59), Lince vehicles, towed artillery (Fh70) and self-propelled artillery (Pzh2000) were sent - in addition to economic contributions. Excluding these last three items, most of the supplies sent were no longer used by the Italian army.

The latest weapon packages sent

.

The latest package (the eighth) of sending military materials and equipment to Ukraine was published in the Official Gazette of 29 December 2023 (Ministerial Decree of 19 December 2023). Sending arrived seven months after the so-called "Seventh Package" of military aid published in the Official Gazette on 31 May 2023. Some indications concerning the Seventh Package were provided by the executive at the end of May. On that occasion, the list of armaments was illustrated by Defence Minister Guido Crosetto during a hearing at Copasir. As in the previous packages, on that occasion the content of the new Ukraine decree was 'secreted' and subsequently published in the Official Gazette. The late May decree was the second measure signed by the Meloni government: the first one dated back four months earlier. According to rumours circulating in those days, equipment was sent on that occasion to protect against the Nbcr risk: suits, protective masks, kits to make water drinkable, as well as ammunition. Also in those days, there was talk of sending additional vehicles, howitzers, missile launchers, machine guns and small arms.

Rules on the import and export of armament materials

.

The control of the movement of armament materials to and from abroad is regulated in Italy byLaw 185 of 1990, last amended by Legislative Decree 105/2012 and supplemented by the implementing regulation set out in Interministerial Decree (Foreign and Defence) No. 19 of 7 January 2013. With Law 118 of 2013, Italy ratified the Arms Trade Treaty (ATT), adopted by the United Nations General Assembly on 2 April 2013 and entered into force on 24 December 2014, which, in regulating conventional arms transfers, provides for hypotheses in which the granting of a licence is strictly refused and hypotheses in which a specific risk assessment is required. Law 185 establishes the general principle that the export, import, transit, intra-community transfer and brokering of armament materials, as well as the transfer of related production licences and production relocation, are subject to State authorisation and control. The rule prohibits the authorisation of the movement of defence-related products when they conflict with the principle of the Italian Constitution that repudiates war as a means of resolving international disputes; with Italy's international commitments, including agreements on non-proliferation; with the fundamental interests of State security, the fight against terrorism and the maintenance of good relations with other countries. Transactions relating to defence-related products are permitted only to companies registered in the Defence Register of Companies. These transactions may only have as recipients foreign governments, international organisations recognised by the Italian government and foreign companies authorised by their respective governments.

Meloni: better to strengthen Kiev defence than to strike in Russia

The government's strategy regarding the crisis in Ukraine was outlined in the last few hours by Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni. Speaking at a Corriere TV forum, the Prime Minister explained that "it is better to strengthen the ability to equip Ukraine with effective anti-area defence systems, a job also done by Italy with the Samp-T, without risking an out-of-control escalation". At a meeting with Meloni on 8 May, NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg praised Italy's support for Ukraine, "including the provision of a Samp T air defence system together with France. "Italy has also signed a bilateral security agreement with Ukraine, contributing to improving the country's defences, supporting the arms industry and countering hybrid threats," a Nato note underlined on that occasion.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti