Basel

Art Market Crisis? Art Basel and Liste defend it

Concerns about the two dates showed caution on the part of collectors, who aimed to obtain discounts on final prices

L’artista Atta Kwami

7' min read

7' min read

The most important week for the art market and for the big brand ofMch Group fairs, Art Basel, ended with the usual success of million-dollar sales, but works with more 'affordable' price levels also found buyers. It was, above all, during the opening that gallery owners concluded or started their negotiations. An opening that, as the gallerists themselves stated, was very hectic, only to leave room in the following days for moments of prolonged calm, so that business was concluded more slowly than usual. Overall, 91,000 visitors passed through the fair (82,000 in 2023), taking into account the days with exclusive admission and the days open to the public. In summary, the tone was positive, but caution prevails and collectors, as several gallery owners pointed out, are very slow in making purchases and the aim of concluding deals is to obtain a discount.

The turnout at Art Basel

.

285 galleries from 40 countries participated in this year's Art Basel and of these, 22 were first-time exhibitors. The prevalence of works by established artists on the secondary market was perhaps the main theme of the fair, as well as the inclusion of works by many names currently featured in the Venice Biennale. And it was precisely the Venice Biennale, as some gallerists pointed out, that was the reason for the low presence of South American collectors, particularly Brazilians, while there was no shortage of Asians. Although some gallery owners reported having sold works to important American collectors, the general impression was that there was a greater European presence - French, German, Belgian, Swiss - than in previous years and that only a few visitors came from the other side of the Atlantic Ocean. The Americans "perhaps prefer Paris" which from the next edition will be called Art Basel Paris and will be held from 18 to 20 October in the iconic and recently restored Grand Palais.

Loading...

L’artista Atta Kwami. Courtesy Goodman

Among gallerists there are those like Jo Stella-Sawicka, senior director of the Goodman Gallery, who states that 'considering the current economic but also political moment with elections all over the world, the balance sheet here at Art Basel was positive, despite the negative views on the art market'. The gallery, founded in Johannesburg, sold several works by Atta Kwami (currently in a solo exhibition at the London gallery) at prices ranging from USD 40,000 to 200,000. Although the Ghanaian painter, who died in 2021, does not have a well-developed secondary market, these numbers far surpass the record of $35,000 set for his 2010 work 'Zongo III' that went on sale at Christie's in early June.

Among Italian gallerists, Massimo De Carlo sold several works at different price levels from 250,000 euro for "This is How We Play Together", Fig. 3 (Marble), 2023 a mando statue by the Elmgreen & Dragset duo, to 120.000 for an acrylic on canvas, 'Rest', 2024 by the artist Lenz Geerk whose portraits, landscapes and still lifes combine the traditions and references of European painting, the artist creates works divorced from their historical context with a unique and recognisable technique, and up to $20.000 for 'Sculpture (Crimson)', 2024, an oil and charcoal on canvas by South Korean artist, born in 1994, Mark Yang who had a solo exhibition last year in the Beijing gallery space in Milan. For Raffaella Cortese, founder of the gallery of the same name, the presence at Art Basel "was productive and, above all, it highlighted how collecting is changing and the most historicised works are now only appreciated by a few collectors". In this regard, the gallery owner exhibited a historical work by Polish artist Miroslaw Balka (price in the region of EUR 220,000) on her stand that attracted the attention of only a few collectors who are 'more respectful towards art'.

Focus on the artists in the Biennial

.

Among the sales was no shortage of artists present at the Venice Biennale. Among them, paintings by Alioune Diagne, representing Senegal in Venice, sold between $32,000 and $85,000 at the Galerie Templon (Paris, Brussels, New York) stand. The Brazilian gallery Gomide and Co. (São Paulo Brazil) sold three ceramic works by the indigenous Guaraní artist Julia Isídrez, featured in the Biennale's main exhibition, 'Foreigners Everywhere' for between $15,000 and $20,000.

Lisson Gallery (Beijing, Shanghai, London, Los Angeles, New York) sold 'Isles of the Blessed XI', 2022 an oil on canvas ($35,000) by Egyptian Wael Shawky representing Egypt. The artist, who works transversally between film, sculpture, performance and drawing, examines and subverts customary notions of national and religious identity, redefining dominant views of history. Also at Lisson were the works of Palestinian-Saudi artist Dana Awartani, featured in the main exhibition with the installation 'Come, let me heal your wounds. Let me mend your broken bones' (2024), a requiem dedicated to the historical and cultural sites destroyed in the Arab world due to wars and acts of terrorism. The installation is made of fabric that is dipped in natural herbal and spice dyes that have medicinal value, exploiting the sacred healing properties embedded in traditional Kerala textile dyeing practices that Awartani has learnt over time. The two works sold, 'Let me mend your broken bones 20', 2024 and 'Let me mend your broken bones 21', 2024 (darns on silk and medicinal dyed paper 8 pieces 27 cm x 36 cm each) are a 'domestic' version of the installation in Bienale (price €20,000 each).

Art Fair Lists

As of next year's Liste Art Fair will have a new artistic direction with the appointment, during the days of the fair, of Nikola Dietrich, director of the Kölnischer Kunstverein in Germany and former head of contemporary art at the Kunstmuseum in Basel. The fair, which hosted 91 galleries from 35 countries, confirmed itself as a platform for research, albeit with some "imperfections" that will require the intervention of the new artistic direction, which will also have to rethink the architecture of the space, which is not being appreciated by operators and collectors.

Installation view Logo Gallery

Many exhibitors shared concerns about the market slowdown, which particularly affected the segment of less established artists. However, on the closing day many gallery owners stated that the fair went much better than expected.

Some of the newcomers, such as Callirrhoë, an Athens gallery founded in 2020 and directed by Olympia Tzortzi, hope to participate again next year because this first experience did not disappoint expectations and the works exhibited by Vasilis Papageorgiou, born in 1991 (prices from 3,000 to 15,000 euros, in Italy he works with UNA Galleria in Piacenza) found buyers from both institutions and private individuals. On display at the Greek gallery's stand were a number of ceramic wall-mounted works bearing the title of the time when they were finished and created from photographs taken at sunset from the balcony of his home in Athens as well as several sculptures.

Very original was the stand of the Kogo Gallery, one of the ten selected this year by the Liste Committee and the Board of Friends of Liste, which received a grant as it was considered particularly courageous in its stand design, which was indeed very playful and invited you to experience it in a performative way. The installation 'Common Issues in Painting and Everyday Life' presented new works by the Latvian artist Elīna Vītola, combining large-scale interactive paintings, tracksuits, a rowing boat and a sugar-enamelled letter through which the artist explores the meaning of entering the space of the artwork and skilfully disseminates the imprints of her previous creative projects touching on existential questions about art (prices from EUR 3,500 to EUR 15,000).

Also satisfied was the Livorno gallerist Gian Marco Casini Gallery at its second participation in Liste with a single show by the Palestinian Hamza Badran (Nablus 1993), whose artistic practice, through the use of video, publications or photography, tackles neo-colonialism, apartheid and racism inside and outside Europe (video, photography and bas-relief were exhibited at the fair with a price range of 2,000 to 7,500 euro) . If video art finds resistance in the other fairs at Liste, there was no shortage of proposals and among them from Tabula Rasa (Beijing, London) the video "The organology of the world" (the fifth edition is on sale for $20,000) which pleased Mark Spiegler, former director of Art Basel, who returned to Liste after the opening night just to review the video and talk to the gallery owner as he considers the artist Musqui Chihying (1985) very interesting. Based in Taipei and Berlin, Musquiqui Chihying, who has already received institutional recognition from the Berlin Biennial in 2022, the Centre Pompidou, as well as numerous institutions in China, presented a project exploring the system of coolie, a form of forced labour that brought individuals from Asia to work on colonial plantations around the world during the 19th century.

Perhaps anticipating a more reflective market, the Milanese gallery Clima brought, to its third appointment with Liste, its most commercially profitable stand to date, says its founder, Francesco Lecci, with sand sculptures by Nicola Martini (priced between 8,000 and 13,000 euros) who, in the last two years, had presented a talking sofa and a stand composed entirely of video works.

Vasilis Papageorgiou«19:53», 2022, ceramic & steel, 43 x 27 x 2 cm, courtesy of the artist; photo by Stathis MamalakisListe Art Fair 2024

The work of Lorenza Longhi, class of 1991, born in Lecco but resident in Zurich, who was presented by Fanta-MLN (Milan) for Liste, was much appreciated. She presented a new series of works that further develop her pictorial approach to the silkscreen technique and the fabrics used, a mix of deadstock and opalescent tyvek, a technical material usually used to protect works that in this series takes a central role, are intentionally not stretched on a frame, but printed using a mesh on which the artist has painted an irregular grid originally found on a piece of flower wrapping paper (prices from 5.000 for the small work to 14,000-16,000 for the larger ones).

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti