Breeding

To ban horse meat yes or no? Italy is divided

A growing number of opinions oppose the proposed law being tabled in the House, in the name of defending culinary tradition and the supply chain

by Silvia Marzialetti

Aggiornato il 20 febbraio alle 12.30

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

Among the divisive topics agitating the country, there also seems to be horse meat. After the news (broadcast by the Sole 24 Ore) of a bipartisan PDL hinged in the Chamber of Deputies banning the slaughter of equids (not only horses and ponies, but also mules, donkeys and hinnies), the debate has been unleashed.

The first to intervene was Gianmarco Centinaio, vice-president of the Senate, a Lega Nord member and former Minister of Agriculture during the Conte government. "Banning the consumption of horse meat would mean deleting a piece of the history of Italian cuisine and also of the identity of some territories," he said. "For this reason, I cannot agree with the bills under discussion in the Chamber, which go in this direction."

Loading...

Apart from the ideological issues (numerous petitions for and against opened on change.org), the culinary identity tradition is the driver most invoked by the front of those opposed to the slaughter ban. Now that the Italian cuisine has gained Unesco recognition, then, the dossier becomes even more delicate.

The list of flagship dishes is long and crosses the whole Boot, from North to South: pastissada in Verona and meatballs in Catania, stracotto d'asino in the Lombardy plain, tapulon in Borgomanero and pezzetti in Valle D'Itria. In Parma, even, the kingdom of the 'caval pisst', local newspapers call the proposal tabled in the Chamber of Deputies a shock. 'The presence of horse and donkey meat on our tables has spanned the centuries and established itself as a deep-rooted tradition,' recalls the Lega Nord senator'.

Among the most fervent supporters of the battle in defence of equids is the ong Animal Equality, whose investigative team has documented - behind some slaughterhouses - serious abuses and violations of animal welfare regulations.

But Centinaio looks ahead. 'I respect the decision of those who, for emotional, moral or ideological reasons, prefer not to eat products derived from some or all animals,' says the vice-president of Palazzo Madama, 'but I think it is right to ask for the same respect for the culture of so many local communities, which is also defined by traditional dishes.

Those who do not accept the discrediting of an entire production sector is Confagricoltura. "The farms operate in compliance with national and European regulations on animal welfare, traceability and food safety," comments the president of the Piacenza section, Umberto Gorra. "These activities are subject to continuous controls, which ensure high standards throughout the supply chain," he continues. "We must be vigilant so that the public debate does not become the umpteenth opportunity to put livestock supply chains in a cone of shadow, which are already too frequently subjected to media processes that do not distinguish between virtuous realities and other isolated cases".

"A ban on the slaughter and marketing of horsemeat would reduce the freedom of choice of many consumers who would no longer be able to find a product that not only represents a source of employment for many workers and income for the many companies in the supply chain, from butchers to breeders to distributors, but also represents a cultural and gastronomic element deeply rooted in our country," said Federcarni-Confcommercio in a note. 'A rule that introduces a generalised ban,' the federation points out, 'risks having a significant impact on consumption habits, economic activities and employment linked to this sector. Federcarni is willing to engage in a constructive debate, hoping that the legislator will carefully evaluate any alternative or corrective regulatory solutions that take into account production and territorial specificities and do not compromise the sustainability of the companies involved.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti