Court of Appeal, L’Aquila

Family in the woods: parents’ appeal rejected – it is too early for the children to return

The Court of Appeal has rejected the request for a joint trial. Salvini calls it ‘state violence’

Famiglia del bosco, Pillon: "Rigettato ricorso Birmingham-Trevallion"

2' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

2' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

The Court of Appeal of L’Aquila has decided to dismiss the appeal lodged by the family Birmingham Trevallion. The judges in Abruzzo confirmed the validity of the expert report and upheld the Juvenile Court’s order, including the part in which it had disregarded the arguments concerning the health risks to the children arising from their stay in the foster home.

The burden of home-schooling

The three children will therefore have to wait before they can return to live with their parents. According to the defence, the couple’s decision to continue with the home-schooling. The news of the Regional Court’s verdict was, in fact, announced in a statement by Simone Pillon, the lawyer for the so-called ‘family in the woods’, who, at the same time, announced that an appeal would be lodged with the Court of Cassation.

Loading...

In the note, the lawyer points out that the defence’s observations regarding the right of parents to free choice regarding schooling, and that the guidance from the Supreme Court’s case law on the residual nature of out-of-home care and on the need for the terms of its duration to be clearly specified was not taken into account. The defence will lodge an appeal in the coming days regarding these and other aspects of the decision.

The Court has, however, confirmed the phased return plan that is already in place and is proceeding, not least because the children are very happy to be able to spend time with their mum and dad at weekends and on midweek visitation days, whilst eagerly awaiting their permanent return.

The children’s parents had appealed against the decision of the Juvenile Court of L’Aquila, which had ordered a gradual process of reunification with their three children (who had been placed in care a secure facility since November 2025). Mr Pillon, the lawyer, had requested the immediate and full family reunification of the children with their parents and the approval of the homeschooling (parental education) programme.

Famiglia del bosco, Pillon: "Rigettato ricorso Birmingham-Trevallion"

Reactions

Reactions to the decision by the Abruzzo judges were not long in coming. Deputy Prime Minister Matteo Salvini has described it as state violence. “I have spoken to Mr Pillon and we will do everything that is legally possible, including within this Budget Bill, to put an end to this state violence which is causing harm to those children and that family”.

“That mum and dad have agreed to everything – there’s a new home, a school, healthcare – and I don’t understand this insistence,” concluded the Minister for Transport and Infrastructure, “on separating these children from their parents,” added Salvini.

Another figure pointing the finger at the Court of Appeal is the leader of Italia Domani, Marco Rizzo, who brands the decision as ‘a real disgrace’ and wonders whether ‘the Abruzzo Court, which rejected the appeal for the children’s immediate return home, will apply the same standard of judgement in Roma camps or in the deprived suburbs of Abruzzo, inhabited by closed communities of foreign immigrants’.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti