Healthcare

Calabria, the case of Cuban doctors fleeing the public health service

Lost track, or almost lost track, of some white coats who arrived from Havana. Blame the regime's economic treatment and controls? For the President of the Region, Roberto Occhiuto, the facts show that 'they are free and perfectly integrated people'. The Asp of Vibo Valentia asks the Prefecture for investigations

by Donata Marrazzo

(Adobe Stock)

5' min read

5' min read

The question was raised right from the start: the agreement signed in 2022 by the Region of Calabria with Cuba for the arrival of 497 doctors from the Caribbean island, in support of the Calabrian health system, had immediately appeared to be a correct intuition, but had raised some doubts, in particular with respect to the actual economic treatment of the professionals. Today, the first defections of the white-collar doctors who arrived from Havana - some to private clinics, some to other countries, or after their holidays, who ended up just off the radar - pose the problem in other terms, with repercussions on the fragile health system of Calabria.

From Vibo to facilities in the Cosenza area, the flight of Cuban doctors

The latest leak concerns the Jazzolino di Vibo Valentia, a hospital where an orthopaedist sent from Cuba, when his contract expired, chose the private sector instead of renewal in the public sector: a job at Villa dei Gerani, a facility accredited with the regional health service. The commissioner of the Asp Vittorio Piscitelli, former prefect of Reggio Calabria, who leads the commissioner trio, appointed a year ago after the dissolution of the body for mafia infiltration, says he is interdicted: "On the case I am waiting for the opinion of the prefecture and the police shortly," says Piscitelli, supported in his work by the executive Gianluca Orlando, an expert in accounting and financial management, and by Gandolfo Miserendino, general manager of Azienda Zero. I am not an expert on residence permits, but I need to understand whether everything is in order. As for the role of the Cuban brigade, its usefulness is out of the question, also in view of the planned expansion of our facility with Pnrr funds'.

Loading...

Another Cuban left the same hospital a few months ago, on his way to Spain: 'His fiancée was supposed to join him,' adds the commissioner of the Asp in Vibo, 'also a doctor enrolled for Calabria, but from what I know, she was stopped at the airport. Other white coats arrived from Cuba on duty at some health facilities in the province of Cosenza are also 'missing'.

The case ends up in Parliament

.

The case ended up in Parliament, with a question from M5S deputy Anna Laura Orrico, who called on governor Roberto Occhiuto 'to guarantee the working conditions of Cuban doctors called to operate in Calabria'. But it was above all a recent journalistic enquiry conducted by Cubanet.org, an independent Cuban newspaper, that turned the spotlight on the conditions of Cuban doctors on secondment from Cuba: it reported minimum salaries, deductions from overtime and thirteenth month bonuses, movements and social activities monitored, or rather controlled.

Occhiuto, slave and underpaid doctors? Rubbish

The President of the Calabria Region, Roberto Occhiuto, also in his capacity as Commissioner for Health, gives an entirely different reading of the facts: 'In recent years, ever since the Cuban doctors have been with us in Calabria, someone has cyclically made slanderous accusations, claiming that white Caribbean doctors are slaves, that they are controlled by the regime, that their families in Cuba are under special surveillance, and other such rubbish. The individual events of recent weeks, however, prove exactly the opposite. Cuban doctors in Calabria,' Occhiuto continues, 'are very free, perfectly integrated in the communities in which they work, some have even married. Calabrian patients appreciate their professionalism. Those who attack this model should agree with themselves. Of two things, either Cuban doctors are slaves or they can do what they want. And even with respect to remuneration, they receive around 4,700 euro gross per month in an Italian bank account, just like their Calabrian colleagues, and they also have, as an incentive, accommodation provided by the Region'.

The first engagement

.

Initially, the white coats arrived from Cuba on the basis of an agreement signed by the Region of Calabria with the Comercializadora de Servicios Medicos Cubanos, which established a monthly budget of EUR 4,700 for each doctor. 'The amounts for the services provided by each professional will be paid by the Region to the Csmc,' the document specified. And also that 'the body will advance each specialist 1,200 euro as a lump-sum reimbursement, plus accommodation and travel expenses. The remaining EUR 3,500 will be paid directly to the Cuban commercial company', based in Catanzaro, from which it operates as a temporary employment company. At the time (2023) it was necessary to provide clarification to the American consulate, via the Ministry of Health.

The double contract

.

The agreement was subsequently modified, and in a certain sense for the better, on the Calabrian side, providing for direct hiring on a fixed-term basis by the health agencies in compliance with Italian law. And yet, according to Cubanet, which also publishes extensive documentation in support of its in-depth study, there are still severe salary cuts, because 'there is also a second contract drawn up with the Cuban agency that assigns all the professionals an allowance equal to 22% of the amount paid by the host government. And it only pays half of the overtime hours worked by the doctors and the 13th month's salary'. The journalist Annarel Grimal, who signed the investigation, writes - and she does so, she says, 'after having access to dozens of internal documents', many of which are published in their entirety in her report - that 'of the 34.50 euros per hour paid by Italy as a basic salary, the doctor receives only 6.68'.

Requests for verifications on fees and protections

It was inevitable, therefore, that the phenomenon would come under scrutiny. Regional councillor Ernesto Alecci (PD) has filed a question for written answer to President Roberto Occhiuto: 'Let there be clarity on the entire health cooperation project with the Cuban doctors, verifying whether they are still actually in service today, how many have left, what controls are in place to assess the progress of the project, and whether there is any intention to review the contractual conditions'.

Former regional council president Mimmo Tallini, an exponent of the Calabrian centre-right, who is critical of Forza Italia's current line, intervenes in the debate by advancing doubts 'on the remuneration, dignity and protection of Cuban workers, and the management of sensitive data on services and operations carried out by specialists'.

Cuban doctors in Calabria until 2027

At the moment, what we know for sure is that the Cuban doctors, whom the Calabrian health service still needs, have been confirmed until 2027. The decree signed by President Roberto Occhiuto renews the agreement with the Comercializadora de Servicios Medicos Cubanos for two years, considering that 'the recruitment of Cuban medical professionals has made it possible to fill serious staffing gaps in Calabrian healthcare facilities, as well as to foster a professional and scientific interchange useful for improving the efficiency of the healthcare services provided'. A necessary extension, pending a structural reform of the health system.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti