Call centres: Parliament opposes AI bots: ‘We need human operators’
Following the Council of State’s confirmation of the legality of AGCOM’s telecoms regulations, the government and the opposition find themselves united in the same aim, albeit through two very distinct initiatives
Key points
The right to speak to a real-life operator, without getting stuck between bots and automated menus, is now on the parliamentary agenda. Following the Council of State’s confirmation of the legitimacy of Agcom’s telecoms regulations, the government and the opposition find themselves united in the same cause, albeit through two distinct initiatives.
Initiatives by Fratelli d’Italia and the PD
An amendment tabled by Fratelli d’Italia to the competition bill and a bill proposed by the PD aim to enshrine in law the requirement for a human operator to answer calls in call centres.
The Council of State’s ruling
The turning point came with the ruling in October in which the Council of State dismissed Fastweb’s appeal and upheld the legality of the 2024 AGCOM regulation on the ‘Regulation and quality of customer service in the electronic communications and audiovisual media services sector’.
The AGCOM Regulation
The provision requires that telephone assistance be provided by a member of staff – excluding the mere arrangement of a call-back – that users should not hear a busy tone but instead receive a message inviting them to call back, and that, at least on weekdays, service provided by a human operator from 8.30 am to 9.30 pm. According to the Council of State, the regulation ‘guarantees a minimum, non-derogable standard’: the possibility of reaching a human operator directly by calling a dedicated number. Fastweb’s model, in which, for a wide range of enquiries, users must book a callback for a later time slot, ‘structurally denies this outcome’.
Response from a human operator
Through an amendment to the Competition Bill, Eliana Longi of Fratelli d’Italia is therefore seeking to introduce a requirement for call centres to provide ‘a prompt response from a human operator’ within 150 seconds. The ‘total waiting time’ – that is, the interval between dialling the number and the moment the caller can speak to an operator – must not exceed this threshold.
