The judgment

Cancer caused by asbestos on ships, soldier recognised as 'victim of duty'

According to the Court of Tempio Pausania, the Ministry of Defence will have to pay 200,000 euro to the man as damages

by Letizia Giostra

Il tribunale di Tempio Pausania. (Ansa)

2' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

2' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

A 'victim of duty': it was with these words that the Tribunal of Tempio Pausania recognised as the cause of death of a serviceman of the Italian Navy the exposure to asbestos during his years of service. But the man could not be informed of the outcome of the ruling, as he had died some time before. He will therefore not be able to collect the EUR 200,000 that the Ministry of Defence has been ordered to pay in damages, money that will in any case be received by the victim's family. For the Sardinian court, prolonged and continuous exposure to carcinogenic fibres played a decisive role in the onset of the tumour that led to the man's death.

The Story

A court case whose protagonist is a man whose initials have been indicated with N.I. to protect his privacy. Behind these two letters is the story of a military man, originally fromLa Maddalena, where he served for twenty years working in close contact with asbestos, a highly carcinogenic fibre and therefore a health risk. The ex-serviceman worked without any kind of protection, inevitably breathing in the toxic substance that, according to the Sardinian court, caused his death.

Loading...

Witnesses: 'We were spraying asbestos'

'It was customary to spray asbestos on extensive surfaces for fireproofing, insulation and anti-condensation purposes,' is what emerged from the account of one of thewitnesses heard during the trial. A widespread practice - according to the testimony collected - on the military ships used at the time.

The deceased man's job was that of a helmsman and specialised mechanic. The killer fibre, according to the testimonies collected, was present in several places where the soldier inevitably came into contact: pipes, engine rooms, bulkheads, panels and other areas of the Arsenal of La Maddalena.

Numerous interventions - in the words of another witness - were carried out 'in the steam-fired kitchens, with external pipes completely insulated with asbestos'.

The diagnosis and subsequent death

The diagnosis of the disease was a pulmonary adenocarcinoma with subsequent brain metastases. The soldier did not have a chance and died at the age of 69. But at first his death was not attributed to contact with asbestos. This was the reason why his loved ones started a legal battle to have the substance recognised as the cause of death.

Ministry of Defence ordered to pay compensation

Compensation for damages of 200,000 euros: this is what the Ministry of Defence owes to the deceased soldier, in addition to the living allowances provided for by law. The inclusion of the man's name in the national list of victims of duty was also ordered. This is not an isolated case, as there have also been other convictions in the past for deaths linked to exposure to carcinogenic substances such as asbestos.

Lawyer: 'Dignity and justice restored'

According to Ezio Bonanni, president of the National Asbestos Observatory and lawyer for the family members, 'the ruling restores dignity and justice to a family that has had to face pain and silence for years'. The lawyer concludes by stating that 'for too long thousands of military personnel have worked in contact with asbestos without adequate protection. This decision once again confirms a historical and health truth that is now indisputable'.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti