Carlo Calenda: 'Without nuclear power, decarbonisation is impossible'
by Emilia Patta
4' min read
4' min read
'Our goal is first of all to start a public opinion battle: all polls show that the majority of Italians are in favour of nuclear power. It is time to bring this technology back to Italy'. This is how Carlo Calenda, leader of Azione and former Minister of Development, launches the popular law proposal to reinsert nuclear power into the Italian energy mix developed with the Einaudi Foundation, the Radicals and a number of associations. 'In 24 hours we reached half of the 50,000 requests. An unexpected response'.
Let's take a step back, Senator Calenda. Why nuclear power?
The first reason is that without nuclear power Italy will never achieve its decarbonisation goals, for the simple reason that to do so with renewables alone would require covering an area like Campania entirely with solar panels. Over the life of a power plant, 60 years, the cost difference between using only renewables and a renewables-nuclear mix is 800 billion, 13 billion a year. Secondly, nuclear is today in the European green taxonomy. Thirdly, nuclear power would solve the fundamental issue of energy dependency, otherwise we have to go on gas. The average construction time for a nuclear power plant, considering that 60 are being built around the world and that already a quarter of Europe's energy is produced by nuclear power plants, is seven years. Now we may take 15 years, but if we never start, we will always be unprepared.
And yet in 2011 there was a referendum won by the anti-nuclearists. They put forward security reasons.
The abandonment of nuclear power, without reason and on the wave of emotion, was the first act of true populism in this country. Fortunately, the orientation of public opinion has changed since then. As for safety, today nuclear power is considered by the United Nations Energy Agency to be the safest energy of all. And I repeat: there is no chance of achieving the decarbonisation goals without nuclear power, so much so that in the United Arab Emirates they are building their second power plant despite being full of gas and oil. By now there is also this awareness in the international green movement. Without nuclear power it is not possible to decarbonise electricity and we are moving towards ever greater electrification, think of cars.


