Opinions

Cybersecurity starts with the Board of Directors

 (Adobe Stock)

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

During the night of 11–12 October, the control units regulating the refrigeration systems in around 700 French supermarkets were remotely tampered with, forcing hundreds of shops to destroy the goods stored in their refrigerated display cabinets. The disaster was not caused by a particularly sophisticated cyber-attack: the target was the control systems of the Danish company Danfoss, one of the leading suppliers of refrigeration solutions to the European retail sector.

Many of the affected control units were at the end of their service life or were protected only by factory default credentials that had never been changed. These devices are connected to the internet for one simple reason: to allow maintenance companies to monitor temperatures and adjust settings without having to send a technician to every shop.

Loading...

And identifying them does not require any exceptional skills: all you need to do is use Shodan, a sort of Google for devices connected to the internet. The gap between the simplicity of the attack and the scale of the damage reveals a growing contradiction. Whilst attention to security is increasing, companies are introducing a proliferation of procedures and certifications that document the existence of controls without demonstrating their effectiveness: security ends up being better described than it is practised. This is clearly illustrated by the figures from the Cybersecurity & Data Protection Observatory at the Politecnico di Milano: in 2025, around 60 per cent of large Italian companies considered their security budget to be adequate, but only 28 per cent were actually resilient to cyber risk.

The proof lies in the timeline. Critical vulnerabilities in two widely used refrigeration control platforms were made public on 9 August. The attack took place on 11 October: sixty-three days later. On 22 October, Forescout, a company specialising in cybersecurity, identified 12,976 such services exposed on the internet across 99 countries. For the most common type of control unit, 80 per cent of installations were still using a version of the software prior to the one that patched the vulnerabilities. In the weeks that followed, similar attacks affected eight other European countries, including Italia.

It is the gap between compliance and security. The former can demonstrate that a process for rectifying vulnerabilities exists; the latter requires verifying that it actually works, within the timeframe dictated by the real risks the organisation faces. Bridging that gap is not, and cannot be, the sole responsibility of the security manager. In French supermarkets, someone had to decide when to switch off the refrigerated display cabinets, withdraw the products and absorb the losses. In which company could such a decision rest solely with the IT manager?

Cybersecurity is a corporate governance responsibility. And for many organisations, it is not merely an organisational choice: it is a legal obligation under NIS2, the 2022 European directive transposed into Italian law by Legislative Decree 138 of 2024. Organisations subject to the regulation must adopt appropriate risk management measures, report any incidents to the National Cybersecurity Agency (ACN) within the prescribed timeframes, and ensure the security of their supply chain. It is the responsibility of the governing bodies to approve these measures and oversee their implementation.

The role of the board of directors, therefore, is not to understand firewalls or attack techniques. It is to know what generates value within the company, which processes make this possible, and what would happen if they were to stop. Only by starting from there can one determine which risks to accept and where to invest in order to reduce them. Without this direction, security is reduced to guidelines that very few people read. And a defrost control unit remains invisible on risk maps until the moment its tampering forces us to empty the fridges.

The proof that security has become an integral part of business decision-making is not the purchase of new technology. It is the ability, at every level of the organisation, to answer one question: how long would it take to get your process up and running again if a cyber incident were to bring it to a standstill tomorrow?

If the answer isn’t immediate, no checklist should make us feel safe.

Lecturer in Cyber Risk Governance and Strategy, Bocconi University

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti