EU Commission on Temu: ‘It breaches the DSA and does not prevent the sale of illegal products’
If the breach of Article 35 of the Digital Services Act is confirmed, the company faces a fine of up to 6 per cent of its total annual turnover
Failure to comply with the rules by failing to mitigate the risk of illegal products being offered on its platform. The European Commission has thus issued a preliminary complaint that Temu, a global e-commerce platform operated by the Chinese company PDD Holdings, has breached the obligations set out in the Digital Services Act (DSA), by failing to take reasonable, proportionate and effective measures to ensure that products sold on the platform comply with EU safety requirements. According to the Commission’s preliminary findings, the risk mitigation measures (Article 35 of the DSA) adopted by Temu are deficient in three respects:
- ineffective checks on product compliance;
- a weak system for content moderation;
- Inadequate penalty mechanism.
Although Temu classifies certain product categories as high risk (for example, toys, electronic devices and cosmetics), it does not prioritise them when carrying out physical checks. In fact, the company appears not to have acted on the results of the spot checks, nor has it stepped up inspections in light of the increase in the number of items on sale.
“Shopping online should not mean running the risk of buying illegal and unsafe products. Under the Digital Services Act, platforms are required to protect users from the risk of illegal content and goods,” commented Henna Virkkunen, Executive Vice-President for Technological Sovereignty, Security and Democracy. “The preliminary findings regarding Temu are a further step towards a safer online world.”
Content moderation and sanctions systems
Among the concerns raised by the EU Commission regarding the Chinese platform is the fact that the moderation system appears to place little emphasis on product safety and the risk posed by unsafe products; that the number of human moderators content moderators has not increased in line with the growth in the number of listings on the platform; that Temu’s penalty system does not effectively target traders, appears excessively fragmented and does not act as a sufficient deterrent. An interesting point to note is that sanctions are applied to individual shops, not to the merchant behind them. Therefore, even if one shop is closed down, the merchant still has numerous others through which to sell.
Relationships under strain from 2024
As early as 2024 the EU Commission had begun to take an interest in Temu’s activities, launching a formal investigation to assess whether the Chinese platform had breached the DSA in areas such as the sale of illegal products, the design of the service (which is potentially capable of creating addiction), the systems used to recommend purchases to users, and access to data by researchers. In May this year, the Commission found that Temu had breached its obligation to carry out an adequate risk assessment, imposing a fine of 200 million euros. In October, however, the Commission approved the action plan submitted by the company to remedy the breach. Now, the new preliminary conclusions concern the company’s obligation to implement concrete measures to mitigate risks, in accordance with Article 35 of the DSA. Temu may now exercise its rights of defence by examining the documents contained in the Commission’s investigation file and responding in writing to the Commission’s preliminary conclusions. However, should the preliminary assessments be confirmed, the EU Commission could adopt a decision finding non-compliance, which may result in a proportionate penalty – up to a maximum of 6 per cent of total annual worldwide turnover – and require the supplier to take measures to remedy the infringement.

