Green procurement: failure to meet minimum criteria is holding back the circular economy
The findings of the Green Procurement Observatory run by Legambiente and the Ecosistemi Foundation: in 2025, the non-compliance rate stood at 36.5 per cent for the Road Infrastructure CAM (in the first year following its entry into force) and at 23.2 per cent for the Construction CAM
The Minimum Environmental Criteria (CAM) have become the new mandatory standard for accessing public procurement contracts in Italia. Monitoring ‘green’ contracts reveals the environmental impact of the public administration and the public sector’s ability (or otherwise) to promote more sustainable, ‘circular’ models of production and consumption. This is why the latest Green Procurement Observatory report by Legambiente and the Ecosistemi Foundation, presented on 16 November in Rome, is making headlines. Failure to comply with the CAMs for Construction and Road Infrastructure risks holding back one of the most advanced sectors of the Italian circular economy: the recovery of construction and demolition waste.
Despite boasting a recycling rate of nearly 80 per cent and high-tech solutions, Italia remains held back in this sector by a lack of opportunities in the public sector. Despite the rigorous European and national regulatory framework (from the REACH Regulation to the End-of-Waste Directive) designed to ensure safety and traceability, recycled materials in the public sector still face outdated tender specifications and cultural barriers. The failure to adopt Environmental Criteria (CAMs) in public procurement creates a bureaucratic bottleneck that paralyses the growth of an industrial sector of excellence that is already poised for the ecological transition of infrastructure.
The Legambiente Observatory
In Italia, the implementation of green procurement is still far from being fully realised, despite the legal obligation. Despite the maturity of the recycled aggregates sector within the Italian economy, the application of the Minimum Environmental Criteria (CAM) for road infrastructure and construction is struggling to gain momentum, penalising two key sectors for the ecological transition. This is highlighted in the report by the Green Procurement Observatory of Legambiente and the Ecosistemi Foundation. According to the figures, in 2025, out of the 617 tenders issued by 51 regional capitals and 481 non-capital municipalities that responded to the survey, the rate of non-compliance with the CAM for Roads stood at 36.5 per cent, whilst for the CAM for Construction it was 23.2 per cent.
With regard to the Road Infrastructure CAM, the delays are attributable to the recent entry into force of the December 2024 decree, which caught the public administration unprepared, with only 56 per cent of officials in regional capitals sufficiently informed and as many as 59 per cent in non-regional capital municipalities either completely or only partially informed. As for the Construction CAM, however, although the requirement has been in place since 2017 and the 2025 amendments were intended to simplify its use, its practical implementation in tender specifications remains a critical issue.
The 2025 races
Legambiente’s Observatory has asked local authorities to identify the main obstacles hindering the adoption of the two CAMs in the 2025 tenders. Particularly notable is the ‘lack of training and practical guidelines’, cited by 39 per cent of county towns and 55 per cent of non-county towns for the Road Infrastructure CAM, and by 55 per cent and 49 per cent respectively for the Construction CAM; the ‘complexity of the design and planning phase’, cited for the Road Infrastructure CAM by 41 per cent of county towns and 33 per cent of non-county towns, and for the Construction CAM by 47 per cent and 45 per cent respectively; Furthermore, ‘difficulty in drafting compliant technical specifications’ was cited for the Road Infrastructure CAM by 51 per cent of county towns and 47 per cent of non-county towns, and for the Construction CAM by 45 per cent and 48 per cent respectively. ‘The implementation of Green Public Procurement through the Construction and Road Infrastructure CAMs now represents one of the most important tests for our country’s ecological transition,’ states Giorgio Zampetti, Director-General of Legambiente. The data we present highlight delays, training gaps and operational obstacles that continue to hinder the full implementation of the CAMs, despite the regulatory obligation and the presence of mature and innovative industrial supply chains. Green Public Procurement cannot be viewed merely as an administrative formality, but must become a genuine lever for industrial policy.”

