Guarantees and collections underpin Christie’s 21st-century catalogue
Signs of fatigue and a total of $145.9 million, with 51 lots sold out of 56 offered following two withdrawals: the works are struggling to reach the upper end of their estimates
Key points
The final evening auction of the long week in New York at Christie’s on 19 November showed clear signs of fatigue, realising $145.9 million with 51 lots sold out of 56 remaining, following the withdrawal of two million-dollar lots by Jeff Koons (estimated at 3–5 million) and Ed Ruscha (estimated at 4–6 million). Of the 25 lots, virtually all the major ones except one (which remained unsold) were guaranteed by third parties and eight directly by the auction house; the role of guarantees appeared to be essential for many works. The first 30 lots in the catalogue came from two collections: that of Antonio Homen Sonnabend, the adopted heir of the great gallery owner Ileana, and Agnes Gund, for the benefit of her Foundation.
Authentic Basquiat
The only lot to exceed the $10 million mark, however, comes from an unspecified European collection; it is the square canvas, measuring over two metres, created by Basquiat in 1983 as a tribute to ‘Leonardo and His Five Grotesque Heads’, featuring figures drawn on an orange background. The guaranteed estimate of 30–50 million was not reached until after the addition of commission on the hammer price of 28 million, totalling 32.9 million dollars, to little fanfare.
Only one other lot – a work by Lichtenstein from the Sonnabend collection – had an opening estimate of at least 10 million, but it sold for well below that, outbid by a one-metre abstract panel painted by Gerhard Richter in 1991, which sold for $9.4 million, from an estimate of $7–10 million, with no protection from guarantees. A similar, smaller abstract canvas from 1990, however, failed to find a buyer at an (excessive) estimate of 6–8 million dollars, despite its prestigious provenance from the private collection of Marian Goodman, who was the leading gallerist for the octogenarian German artist.
The Homen Sonnabend collection
For the 19 lots remaining after the withdrawal of Jeff Koons’s kitsch porcelain ‘sculpture’ inspired by cartoons – with 13 lots guaranteed by third parties and the remainder by the auction house – the total result came close to $42 million, led by a 1962 ‘Campbell’s Soup’ by Andy Warhol, which exceeded its estimate to reach $9 million, outbidding another example of Pop Art from 1963 ‘Large Spool’ by Roy Lichtenstein, which sold for 8.7 million (against an estimate of 10–15 million). Many lots struggled to reach their low estimates before the addition of commissions, including works by Jeff Koons, two works by Rauschenberg, two by Jasper Johns (including one at 3.3 million, from an estimate of 3–5 million) and Anselmo (115,000 dollars, below the estimate of 200–300,000).
The best performance was achieved by a design object, a large, strictly geometric table by Jean Prouvé from 1956, which was hotly contested up to 1.7 million, well above the high estimate of 1 million dollars.
The Gund collection
The ten lots from the Gund collection fetched $25.7 million, of which $7.1 million was paid for a painting by Vija Celmins ‘Ocean’ from 1990, estimated and guaranteed at $6–8 million, and results exceeding expectations for a small-scale 1961 composition by Robert Ryman, which sold for $3.6 million against an estimate of $1.5–2 million, a small ‘Gold Painting’ by Rauschenberg from 1953, which sold for 2.2 million (estimated at 1–1.5 million), and the 88-year-old Chicago artist Jim Nutt with an intimate 1999 female portrait, ‘Loom’, which was hotly contested at over $1 million, from an estimate of $250,000–$350,000. Only three lots were guaranteed by third parties, apart from Celmins, the 1997 bronze sculpture by Cy Twombly exceeded its estimate of 2–3 million to reach 3.5 million dollars, whilst the work on paper by Lichtenstein may have been bought back by the guarantor at 1.2 million dollars. A second work by Celmins that was not part of the collection – a night sky painted in 2009–13 – fetched $4.5 million, right in the middle of its $3–5 million estimate.









