He was not absent, the 'underwear' policeman must be compensated by the municipality
The Supreme Court enhances the criminal judgment, a trial that had ended with the formula because the fact does not exist
2' min read
2' min read
From symbol of absenteeism to victim of bad administration. The Cassazione puts an end to the judicial odyssey of Sanremo municipality employee Alberto Muraglia, who became known in Italy as the Vigile in 'underwear'. The worker had been sacked in 2015 following an anti 'slacker' investigation by the Guardia di Finanza, and had ended up in court on charges of being a 'card cheat'. He was absent unjustifiably in some cases, and caught on camera stamping his badge in 'skimpy clothes', as stated in the appeal that the municipality lost. The local authority will now have to compensate the former municipal police officer with approximately EUR 227,443.36: EUR 130,000 plus 18 monthly payments.
The Supreme Court, in sentence 20109, confirmed the revocation of the dismissal decided by the Court of Appeal, the reinstatement in the workplace and, in addition, compensation for damages. Although the municipal police officer will not return to duty because he has already resigned. Muraglia had ended up in the centre of media attention after he was immortalised in a photo while punching his time card to go to work without his trousers because, according to the prosecution, he then went home to sleep instead of taking up duty. During the trial his lawyer, Alessandro Moroni, proved instead that Muraglia actually started work even earlier. Appointed caretaker of Sanremo's fruit and vegetable market, Moroni woke up every morning at 5.30 a.m. to open the gates of the market and check that the spaces were empty for the hawkers' stalls, then went on duty at 6 a.m. as town policeman. He performed the duty of caretaker in exchange for free accommodation in the market building, without any monetary remuneration. He therefore stamped in déshabillé, but then, in the opinion of the judges, got dressed and went to work..
The Criminal Judgment Valued in the Supreme Court
.The Court of Cassation, in rejecting the Municipality's appeal, valorised the sentence adopted in the criminal proceedings, which had ruled out absenteeism and fraud to the detriment of the State. A trial, for the same facts underlying the disciplinary proceedings, which ended with the formula "because the fact does not exist". A formula that affects "the very materiality of the facts (and not merely the non-criminal relevance of the same)".
According to the Supreme Court, "the exclusion of the constituent elements of the criminal offence did not leave any other factual elements remaining that would allow the affirmation of an independent disciplinary relevance of the conduct, concluding, therefore, that 'the criminal judgement fully covers both the historical facts and the subjective element to which the Municipality of Sanremo attributed disciplinary relevance'. Consequently, there were the conditions to consider the binding nature of the finding in criminal proceedings also in civil proceedings.

