Tech

The hidden fatigue of streaming: how football puts Italian networks under stress

Bringing streaming matches to Italian screens is an expensive and complex technological undertaking, involving broadcasters, CDNs and telephone operators in a race against time to avoid congestion and disruption

by Alessandro Longo

4' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

4' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

Bringing streaming football to our televisions is an endeavour with much effort, out-of-control costs, and little glory. There is no glory because consumers expect the highest quality, always; they take it for granted. They don't want to miss any action and of course the video quality must be acceptable, high resolution and smooth. Behind all this, however, there is a chain of actors working in unison, even in real time, like firemen ready to put out any fire as it breaks out. Read a network congestion problem that can turn users into angry fans against the streaming provider or their telephone operator.

This was the outcome of an event in Rome, organised in November by Namex (a non-profit consortium that manages the interchange point between operators in Rome). A rare moment of confrontation between many of the actors in this supply chain.

Loading...

The problems and solutions highlighted are numerous. Some are little known.

'In Sky, where I used to work, satellite television was a single video stream, received from a set-top box that was the same for everyone and very controlled,' says Vincenzo Roggio, head of distribution engineering at Dazn. 'With streaming, the scenario changes completely: there is no single format that can be read, interpreted, decoded by all devices,' because the signal has to reach any device connected to the internet. The content - football, in this case - is therefore produced, processed and converted into 'different formats' to cover as wide a variety of devices as possible. In addition, it must be encrypted to protect rights (against piracy).

After this step, the cdn, the content delivery networks, come into play. The metaphor is that of a large parcel distribution system. If Amazon had only one warehouse in Italy, it would never be able to serve people well across the boot. That is why we need many small 'warehouses' with goods, close to the customer. On the Internet they are called caches. Computers with lots of memory, present in the networks of all Italian operators and also at the interchange points. They contain files that are heavy and in great demand by users. They can be Windows updates or a popular game; films, TV series. Users receive them from the cache closest to them. Thus, higher quality and fewer problems can be guaranteed.

In the case of football or other live events it is more difficult, because everything happens in real time. With updates and films, the file can be cached in good time. With football, the content is filmed by the cameras and then immediately distributed along the cache network, close to the users. This work for Dazn is done by Mainstreaming, an Italian company founded in 2013 and its sole partner worldwide for cdn.

Italy has been the worldwide laboratory of this evolved distribution model, says Philippe Tripodi, co-founder of Mainstreaming. This company has about 500 cache computers in Italy; 2 thousand worldwide. Each one costs between 15-30 thousand euros because it has to be very fast and have a lot of memory. Among its main competitors, there is Akamai's cdn (a global player). Even the big tech companies, however, now have their own cdn, which they use together with those of specialised players. "+Also in the Ixp (interchange centres) there are caches of the main players of digital content and services," explains Flavio Luciani, Cto of Namex. "They serve small and medium-sized operators, who do not have access to other caches. And also to large operators when their caches become saturated during derbies."

Dazn's debut on Serie A in Italy was in 2021. Since then everything changes, even for a telephone operator, as Giulio De Nicola, manager of IP & DC Network Engineering at Fastweb + Vodafone, explains. "Before, we used to size the network based on average traffic peaks. Now we do it on absolute peaks. It's the only way not to upset the customer and risk losing him, in the intense competition that now exists between operators".

As a result, the operators' network is oversized most of the year, 'empty 90% of the time (when there are no evening matches). But it must be dimensioned to hold 16 events per year'.

The challenge is complex, agree Tripodi, De Nicola and Roggio, not least because it is impossible to predict with any certainty, in advance, which cities the most traffic will come from; nor whether there will be network problems due to some technical failure along the supply chain (a computer or network router that breaks down, electricity missing in one place). These are situations that sometimes emerge only during the game or shortly before, and then the supply chain operators have to gear up in no time. For example, by moving capacity from one side to the other; or by installing additional caches, with a logistical effort to be made urgently. When Cagliari went up to Serie A, says Roggio, the priority was 'to go and put the server in Cagliari' to avoid congestion throughout Sardinia. De Nicola tells of a cache to be installed in Naples: they realised at the last minute that the router was missing. To remedy this, 'a person from Fastweb took the server, brought it to an autogrill in Bologna, and from there a relay race with vans started to bring everything back'.

A lot of effort, a lot of operational and network costs, to manage a few events per year and not lose customers. This is live streaming in Italy today. A problem that also concerns other countries, of course; but here it is more serious because it clashes with the low margins of telephone operators. The costs of offers are low, there is a lot of competition. So far the challenge has been to guarantee quality for the customer, always. Now the challenge is to make this sustainable for the operators. How to do this? To this dilemma, for now, even since the Namex event, there is no answer.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti