Impaired loans, how profits could grow for the sector
Servicers report an increase in recoveries, but not in margins. The real boost could come from entrusting the collection, through Amco, of local authorities' assets
Key points
Recovery rates of impaired loans up, servicer profits down. With one hope for the sector: the upturn in margins entrusted to the possible choice of the State to entrust the collection of local authorities' credits to private individuals. These are, in a nutshell, the indications emerging from the first "Italian study dedicated to the Npe sector", drawn up by the Alma Iura study centre in collaboration with the consultancy firm EY. The field research, which involved 85% of market operators, is one of the topics of the XII Npl&Utp Congress on Wednesday 29 October in Verona.
Investigation (almost) across the board
At the traditional annual meeting, where the main exponents of an industry that is managing a stock of around 300 billion in difficult loans converge, the first effects of the countermeasures taken by operators to the declining amount of NPL and Utp portfolios sold by banks, which have now reached a physiological level, will be seen.
According to the survey, the credit servicer sector is therefore containing the effects of the lower flows of impaired credits coming from banks, with a modest reduction in margins, and is looking at the large stock of uncollected state credits as a possible new area of growth. Not only. Greater concentration among operators - above all the integration between DoValue and Gardant and the takeover bid launched by Banca Ifis on Illimity - and greater efficiency in credit recovery activities has made it possible to contain to a minimum (-3%) the average drop in profitability of a sector that, according to the financial statements of the main companies, still maintains solid operating results.
Margins under pressure
Assessed through the cost/income indicator (operating costs on total revenues), margins show a limited reduction of 3% from 2022 to 2024. During this period, the number of the 'best' (i.e. those who show a higher average marginality) has decreased, but also that of the 'last in the class'. "The pressure on margins," emphasises Michele Thea, EY partner, Europe West Npe Leader, "is pushing the market in the right direction for operational efficiency, as the weakest players are declining.
Credit Recovery Performance
In the corporate segment, there was an increase in recovery performance mainly among loans with a public guarantee. The Tmr (average recovery rates) defined as the ratio between total collections in the reporting period and the Gbv (gross book value, i.e. the gross value of the loan before any write-downs or losses) recorded at the beginning of the same period are 9.1% for Mcc-Sace guaranteed Utp and 2.5% for NPLs with a "strongly increasing" trend over the period 2022-2024, respectively.


