Current accounts and payment cards

Refunds in the bank must start without asking customers for a prior complaint

By law, it is not due and could turn out to be a double-edged sword because the lending institution could cling to some detail therein in order not to carry out the immediate planned reimbursement

3' min read

3' min read

Report to the carabinieri? There is time to make one. In the event of theft, loss, embezzlement, cloning or unauthorised use of payment instruments, the first thing to do is to block the account or card from functioning and ask the bank to reimburse the amount of the unauthorised and disallowed transactions by the customer. Then all that remains is to wait for the bank's response, which must be given within 15 days.

At the counter, they cannot subordinate taking charge of the file to the completion of burdensome operational fulfilments or - as often happens - to the request for additional documentation such as a copy of the complaint to the Authorities, which may be requested for the purposes of the investigation, but later. This was reiterated by the Bank of Italy in a communication sent on 17 June to the banking system, which continues to turn a deaf ear to this issue, which has now become a scourge.

Loading...

In the first instance, in order not to reimburse, the bank would have to ascertain that the disallowed transaction was caused by the failure to comply with the obligations imposed on the user himself (e.g. custody of the payment instrument) as a result of his conduct characterised by wilful misconduct or gross negligence. Otherwise, the bank is obliged to promptly refund the amount of the unauthorised transaction, without requiring an immediate reporting of the account holder to the authorities.

Re-crediting of the sums must take place by the end of the business day following the day on which the notice of disallowance was received. This is without prejudice to the bank's right to prove, even at a later date, that the user has acted wilfully or with gross negligence, and in that case to obtain a refund of the refunded amount from the user. The bank may also not refund immediately, but only if it has a justified suspicion that the unauthorised transaction resulted from fraudulent activity by the customer.

The report, therefore, is not due and could turn out to be a double-edged sword because the bank could cling to some detail therein in order not to proceed with the immediate reimbursement.

In order to eradicate the phenomenon and the pitfalls that now come from everywhere (via telephone, mail, web, SMS, whatsapp, etc.) and strengthen protection for citizens, the Bank of Italy is moving on several fronts. It has also launched an information campaign against scams together with consumer associations. And after issuing an initial warning to financial intermediaries on 30 October 2023, the supervisory authority conducted an inspection investigation that led the men from Via Nazionale to reiterate to the banks that they must comply with the reference regulatory framework (Legislative Decree 11/2010). In particular, unfounded refusals and shortcomings in the execution of refunds were found, in relation to the time required to process disallowances often burdened by fulfilments - first and foremost the complaint - borne by customers, although not required by law.

Banca d'Italia has therefore once again invited banks to adopt a specific internal policy for the management of disallowances in line with the rules, to launch appropriate initiatives to raise the awareness of staff at the counter, and to widely inform customers on the timeframe and procedures to be followed to obtain reimbursement. The Bank of Italy's objective is to make bank users aware of their rights and invites them to report to it banks that do not follow the instructions provided by the rules.

Copyright reserved ©
  • Gianfranco Ursino

    Gianfranco UrsinoResponsabile Plus24

    Luogo: Milano

    Argomenti: Fondi comuni, Etf, Assicurazioni, Conti correnti, Conti deposito, Mutui, Polizze fideiussorie, Anatocismo, Usura, Risparmio postale, Libretti Coop, Banche, Borsa, Consob, Banca d’Italia, Abf, Acf, Oam, Ocf, Consulenza finanziaria, Fondi pensione, Casse di previdenza, Fintech

Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti