EU lawyer

Increased remuneration for publishers for the digital use of content

Negotiations with providers, supervised by a regulatory body, are lawful. And publishers may refuse to allow the use of their content or authorise it free of charge

oatawa - stock.adobe.com

2' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

2' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

Remuneration to be guaranteed to publishers of journalistic publications for the use of their content by information society service providers (ISPs). The Advocate General of the Court of Justice of the European Union, referred to by the Belgian Constitutional Court to assess the compatibility with EU law of the national legislation introducing a negotiation mechanism between publishers and ISPs regarding the online use of their publications, submitted his opinion yesterday, which is essentially in favour of the new legislation.

The case

According to the Advocate General, in a case brought by a number of Google subsidiaries, Spotify, Meta, Streamz, Sony Music Entertainment, Universal Music and Warner Music, when the FSSI reuses a publication already made available online by the publisher, such use constitutes an independent act falling within the publisher’s exclusive right.

Loading...

Supervised trading

The Advocate General also considers that a Member State may provide for a negotiation procedure supervised by an administrative authority and require FSSIs to provide publishers with the information necessary to determine any remuneration. However, the information must be limited to what is strictly necessary, with publishers obliged to ensure its confidentiality.

The powers of publishers

The publisher must, however, retain the right to refuse the use of its publication or to authorise it free of charge. The parties must also remain free not to enter into a contract. The Advocate General refers to, and places particular emphasis on, the precedent set by the judgment of 12 May 2026, Meta Platforms Ireland (Fair compensation).

Copyright

As regards the right to remuneration for authors and artists, Belgian law establishes a residual right. This right allows authors and artists to retain a right to remuneration directly from broadcasters, even when they have assigned their exclusive rights to a producer. This right, which is non-transferable and inalienable, is exercised through collective management organisations.

Dissociation

According to the Advocate General, EU law does not, in principle, preclude a mechanism of this kind, which separates the right to authorise the exploitation of a work or performance from the right to receive remuneration. Rights holders must, however, retain the possibility of authorising such exploitation free of charge.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti