International Scenarios

India a candidate for the new centre of gravity of the world

From the Gulf to Imec, oil, diaspora and trade corridors shift the axis towards New Delhi. Sapelli reads the Indian rise as one of the great trajectories of the new world order

by Nino Amadore

Capire il Medio Oriente guardandolo dall’India
Nella foto: Francesco Carluccio, Luca Greco, Giulio Sapelli

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

Today it is a seemingly silent giant, but India is destined to become a hegemonic power. Certainly not immediately, but in fifty years time it may be so. At least according to Giulio Sapelli, economic historian, former professor at the University of Milan, president of the Manlio and Maria Letizia Germozzi Foundation of Confartigianato. A scholar accustomed to reading economic facts in the long run of history.

It is from this depth of vision that, in the panel 'Understanding the Middle East by looking at it from India' at the Trento Festival of Economics, Sapelli proposed a clear key: to understand the Middle East, one must also look at it from New Delhi. Because India is no longer a periphery of the world but one of its next centralities. With him were Luca Greco, editor of the Giornale d'Italia, and Francesco Carluccio, an economics student at the Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore.

Loading...

Carluccio, who was born in 2005, had already been a speaker at the Trento 2025 Festival in the panel 'The return of the non-aligned, starting with India', after being selected among the winners of 'Le Voci del Domani'. This year he returned to the same thematic axis, shifting his gaze to the Middle East.

Introducing the topic was Greco, starting with numbers. India is the first country in the world by population: around 1.4 billion inhabitants, 17% of humanity. It still has a GDP per capita that is far from that of the West, but it has numbers, industry, a middle class and political ambitions that make it unattainable. Greco called it 'a silent, seemingly silent giant' and 'an important geography to understand'.

Sapelli picked up the theme by rejecting a word that is abused today. 'I will never use the term geopolitics,' he said. He prefers to speak of 'international relations': power, economy, routes, states, ruling classes, domestic politics shaping foreign policy. The world, for him, has entered 'a great transformation of the weight of economic and geostrategic relevance'. Asia returns to the centre after the Western interlude. 'We are back to before the 18th century'.

In this new geography of power, India is the democratic alternative to China: a harsh, unequal democracy, criss-crossed by religions, castes, minorities and parties. But precisely this complexity, according to Sapelli, makes it a different historical subject. 'India is a great mass democracy.

The transition from the India of Jawaharlal Nehru, father of independent India and non-alignment, to that of Narendra Modi, leader of the Bharatiya Janata Party and premier since 2014, is for Sapelli a caesura. The former looked at the Middle East within the post-colonial and Third Worldist framework; the latter sees it as a strategic platform of energy, security, migrant labour, trade routes and competition with China.

Here, the Middle East stops being just the theatre of wars. Seen from New Delhi, it becomes a living space. Carluccio has given this entanglement an effective formula: between India and the Gulf countries there is a relationship of 'substantial mutual hostage'. India needs oil and gas; the Gulf needs India to sell energy. 'Neither side wants to retreat'.

According to Carluccio, India imports about 60 per cent of its crude oil from the Middle East, but buys where it is convenient: 'It goes to buy crude oil, it goes to buy gas where it is convenient, it does not make a big deal about civilisational or moral ties. The war in Ukraine has made this pragmatism more evident: New Delhi continued to buy Russian crude, refined it and put it back on the markets. "India has no fields, but it does have refineries. Its strength, however, is also vulnerability: energy demand is rigid. "It has a demand in the short term that is completely inelastic. A crisis in Hormuz or between Iran and Israel directly touches India's productive heart.

The other constraint is human. Almost nine million Indians live in the major Gulf countries: the 'old diaspora', that of arms rather than brains. Remittances are lymph for India, but behind it is the kafala system, which binds the worker to the employer and limits his freedom. 'The Gulf has cheap labour, India has remittances'. Sapelli grasped the political node: 'There, those who control migration are the states'.

Finally, the IMEC, the India-Middle East-Europe Economic Corridor: an alternative route to the Chinese Silk Road, from India to the Gulf, then to Israel and Europe, with Haifa as the Mediterranean hub. Carluccio puts the brakes on: IMEC is 'a good initiative that is unlikely to be successful', because the stretch between Jordan, Israel and Haifa requires private capital that is difficult to mobilise.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti