After the power cut

Microsoft: now that the services are up and running again, is it possible to claim compensation?

The service disruptions affected 430 million customers in 70 countries. The resulting losses vary depending on the estimates, but amount to hundreds of millions of euros in any case

2' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

2' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

Over 130,000 reports in the United States alone, disruption affecting more than 70 countries and an estimated 430 million customers affected. A few hours after Microsoft’s services were restored, it is time to take stock of the actual and potential damage. The rating agency Morningstar Dbrs estimates global insured losses of between 100 and 400 million dollars, “should the company offer credit and other compensation to customers”.

According to the Independent, initial estimates suggest a cost of ‘billions of pounds’ due to disruption to communications, transactions and productivity, even for organisations that do not use Microsoft services. Speaking to the same publication, Samuel Mather-Holgate, director of the financial consultancy firm Mather & Murray Financial, told the same publication that the outage could become one of the most economically damaging in the history of technological incidents, adding that most businesses ‘will recover little more than service credits from Microsoft’.

Loading...

The consequences in Italia

In Italia, Codacons has called in a statement for ‘automatic compensation for citizens and businesses affected by the blackout’, given that ‘even a few hours’ outage can lead to production slowdowns, delivery delays, lost sales opportunities and difficulties in managing customer relations’. As regards financial compensation, two scenarios are possible: on the one hand, refunds or contractual credits granted directly by Microsoft; on the other, the activation of an insurance policy, if previously taken out by the affected company to cover the costs of operational downtime. ‘In any case,’ as lawyer Nicola Fabiano, an expert in digital rights, states, ‘the cyber insurance policy may cover the costs of the incident, but the obligations regarding security and, where applicable, notification, remain with the company. In Italia, administrative penalties are uninsurable. And if inaccurate statements or omissions regarding security measures relevant to the risk were to be detected, the compensation could be reduced or even forfeited.”

It is no coincidence that cybersecurity expert Paolo Ballanti confirms that, “the chances of obtaining compensation depend on the contractual terms, the guarantees covering business interruption and unforeseen disruption, the causes of the incident and any exclusions” From a contractual perspective, the specialist website Office Watch reports on the Microsoft 365 Service Level Agreement, which stipulates that the sole remedy for such cases is a credit against the subscription fee, amounting to 25 per cent, 50 per cent or 100 per cent depending on the duration of the disruption; this is not automatic and does not include compensation for lost sales or overtime.

For European consumers, the terms of the Microsoft Services Agreement exclude indirect damages, including loss of profit, except in cases of wilful misconduct or gross negligence. ‘Being insured against cyber-attacks,’ Ballanti continues, ‘does not necessarily mean being protected against every form of digital disruption’. “For the insurance market,” he concludes, “the real problem is the accumulation of risk: when thousands of companies depend on the same provider, a single incident can trigger simultaneous claims on an international scale. These are scenarios that require insurers to rethink their assessment models, compensation limits and the management of aggregate exposures, without compromising on offering businesses truly effective protection.”

Copyright reserved ©

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti