Social media

Class action against Meta and TikTok: the Court of Milan adjourns the case pending the enactment of a law

The lawyers representing Moige and a group of families had requested ‘an urgent injunction’

BANGKOK, THAILAND- 02 July 2018 :Hands of man use Iphone 7 plus with applications of social media stnazkul - stock.adobe.com

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

The latest hearing in the first injunctive class action against Meta, the owner of Facebook and Instagram, and TikTok, was due to take place today, 19 November in Italia. Lawyers Stefano Commodo and Stefano Bertone, representing the Italian parents’ movement Moige and around ten families, before entering the courtroom, before the Milan Civil Court, had requested ‘an urgent injunction, which could be issued as early as today or, in any case, very shortly’. However, the Milan Civil Court has decided to postpone the hearing until 21 January, pending clarification, essentially, as to whether specific regulations on banning the use of social media by minors will be approved in the meantime, as emerged two days ago by an amendment to the Security Decree. “Now we have to wait another two months,” commented lawyer Stefano Bertone, of the Ambrosio e Commodo law firm. “This is a decision with which we do not agree, given that every day and every week there are cases linked to pathological social media addiction; therefore, a two-month postponement – 60 days – is extraordinarily long compared to the caution we were calling for. And it is based on a press release – adds the lawyer – not on a law. So it is a piece of news that was bandied about on the spur of the moment, of which nobody has any certainty.”

Meta and TikTok have agreed to the postponement proposed by the judges and subsequently decided upon following a brief deliberation. In particular, a Meta spokesperson stated: ‘We know that parents are concerned about the safety of their teenage children online, and that is precisely why we continue to work to help them protect them. We strongly reject these allegations, which ignore our long-standing commitment to supporting young people’, the spokesperson continued. “Teen accounts offer default safeguards that limit who can contact teenagers, the content they can access and the time they spend on Facebook and Instagram. We stand by our work and will continue to go the extra mile to protect young people and ensure their safety.”

Loading...

Class action for an injunction

The injunctive class action currently before the Civil Court of Milan is the first of its kind at European level and has been brought by Moige, a group of families and the law firm Ambrosio & Commodo of Turin, under case number 29994/2025. In a nutshell, there are three claims put forward in the injunction class action:

  • genuine age verification, with a ban on users under 14, and accounts suspended until their age has been verified;
  • the removal of infinite scrolling, autoplay and algorithmic recommendations designed to keep users engaged;
  • accurate information on the health risks and addiction.

It is estimated that there are approximately 3.5 million Italian children aged between 7 and 14 who are active on these platforms using unverified or false information. Among those who have brought the case are the parents of a 12-year-old girl who took her own life in February 2024.

Meta’s position

In certain passages of one of the latest submissions filed by Meta ahead of the hearing on 19 November, it is stated that the ‘measures requested’ by Moige and certain families, in the class action brought against the best-known social networks, ‘infringe upon the freedom of expression of minors, which includes free access to social media’, the ‘constitutional right to privacy of minors and parents’ and the right of parents ‘to educate their children freely’.

In response to the allegation that ‘Meta’s social media platforms and TikTok generate and exacerbate mental health and behavioural disorders’, particularly amongst minors, and that ‘not only are they aware of the effects of pathological addiction, but they actively seek to induce and create it in users’ because it is the ‘core of their business model’, Meta’s lawyers counter that ‘these are factual and scientific claims that are entirely unfounded’, as ‘there is no scientific consensus recognising the existence of a causal link between children’s use of Facebook and Instagram and psychological harm to them’ and ‘there is no diagnostic category of “social media addiction”’.

Meta’s lawyers, whilst challenging the Italian courts’ jurisdiction over the case, point out that the European Commission “has blocked the adoption of national measures for 12 months, whilst negotiations on the EU Kids Act are ongoing”. It is up to the legislator, ‘in particular the EU legislator, to establish measures that restrict freedom of expression (including that via social media)’.

TikTok’s position

Similar conclusions are drawn in a submission by TikTok, which states that claims regarding ‘brain changes, anxiety, depression, sleep or other symptoms are not, in any case, substantiated by the necessary causal link’.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti