Court of Trieste

Intentional mother recognised after death: first time in Italia

The judges declared the girls to be the daughters of both mothers, also ordering that the surname of the mother of intention be given

family, child and parenthood concept - happy mother walking with baby stroller in park.

2' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

2' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

For thefirst time in Italia, a intentional parenthood action has been brought by the State to obtain judicial ascertainment of the filiation relationship with a deceased person. The Court of Trieste has, in fact, judicially recognised the maternity of the intentional mother, in the meantime deceased, of two children born following a medically assisted procreation carried out abroad by her partner.

The intentional mother, a professor of Greek and Roman archaeology at the Department of Humanities at the University of Trieste, died on 19 May 2024. At the birth of her daughters - now aged 8 and 4 - she had not been able to proceed with their recognition, as in Italia the declaration would have been refused by the competent offices because it was contrary to current domestic law.

Loading...

Court action

The path followed was therefore, a few months after the death, that of the judicial action taken to ensure the girls the full recognition of theparental bond with the woman who had consciously and responsibly shared the parenting project with her partner. The ruling will result in the daughters' full access to all the legal, inheritance and social security protections associated with thestatus of daughters, including the acquisition of the status oflegitimate heirs and the right to benefit from the social security and welfare benefits provided by the law in favour of the deceased parent's children.

The proceedings were followed pro bono by the advocates of the Lenford Network.

Accepting the application for judicial recognition of parenthood in its entirety, the court declared the children to be the daughters of both mothers, also ordering the attribution of the surname of the intentional mother.

The reactions

"A judgement that restores legal dignity to a family history interrupted by a very serious loss, and that reaffirms the primacy of the minors' interest in affective, identity and legal continuity," says lawyer Patrizia Fiore. The lawyers Giulia Patrassi and Valentina Pontillo emphasise that 'the Court has established that the filiation relationship can also be ascertained with regard to a mother who is now deceased, when the shared procreative will is proven. This is an important milestone that reinforces the principle that the protection of the personal and family identity of children must remain at the heart of the legal system'.

Lawyer Manuel Girola adds that "the ruling is also relevant from a procedural point of view, recognising state action as a tool capable of filling a protection gap in cases where voluntary recognition is no longer possible. This opens up a useful avenue also for other similar situations, in which the parenting of intention can be fully recognised, even in the absence of a biological link'.

The President of the Lenford Network, lawyer Vincenzo Miri, stated that "the action is of particular importance because, in this case, we were able to overcome the obstacle represented by the impossibility of proceeding to the recognition of parenthood in the absence of a prior declaration of recognition and without being able to resort to adoption, a remedy that is not feasible when the intended parent is already deceased".

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti