The UN report

Birth rate, in Italy the first brake is absent or unstable work. Global alarm on the "epidemic of loneliness"

Presented the 2025 edition of the State of the World Population, edited by Unfpa and launched in Italy with Aidos

4' min read

4' min read

In Italy it is work - poor, absent or unstable - that is the first factor indicated as a brake on the full realisation of the desire to have children. This is revealed in the Report on the State of the Population in the World 2025, entitled "The Real Fertility Crisis", presented on Tuesday by Unfpa at the Sapienza University of Rome in Italy, together with Aidos. One hundred and sixty pages containing a survey carried out with YouGov by interviewing 14 thousand people in 14 countries (including ours) where 37% of the planet's inhabitants live: ordered from lowest to highest fertility rate, they are South Korea, Thailand, Italy, Hungary, Germany, Sweden, Brazil, Mexico, the United States, India, Indonesia, Morocco, South Africa and Nigeria.

One in five cannot fulfil their desire to have children

.

The results - illustrated by Mariarosa Cutillo (Unfpa) and discussed by Elena Ambrosetti (Sapienza), Laura Aghilarre of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Serena Fiorletta (Aidos), together with the Dem senator Sandra Zampa - confirm the worrying percentage of those who fail to realise their fertility intentions. While a high number of unwanted pregnancies persist, there is also a majority of people who wish to have two or more sons and daughters without having any or who would like to have more. Almost a fifth of the over-18s surveyed (18%) believe that they will not be able to have the number of children they would like. If we narrow the circle to the over-50s, as many as 31% report having had fewer children than they would have liked, compared to 12% who say they have had more and 19% who say they are satisfied.

Loading...

The failure to support individuals' reproductive choices

.

When respondents of all ages were asked about their experiences, almost one in three (32%) said that they had (or their partner had) had an unwanted pregnancy. Almost one in four (23%) experienced a time when they wanted a child, but felt unable to fulfil this desire at the time. Of these, more than 40% said they had to give up altogether. The report calls it 'alarming' that almost 13% of the respondents experienced both an unwanted pregnancy and obstacles to the possibility of having a desired child (and in some countries this percentage exceeds 20%). A sign of the inability of national systems to support the reproductive decision-making process of individuals. In other words, everywhere we look, 'people struggle to realise their reproductive aspirations freely'.

Economic issues are the first brake

.

Exploring the reasons behind the failure to fully realise the desire to have children, it emerges that economic issues (finances, housing, work) are a determining factor. On average, only 12% cite infertility, 7% generic fertility barriers or medical treatment and 12% illness. As many as 39%, on the other hand, point to economic difficulties, 19% to housing, 12% to the absence of adequate childcare and 21% to unemployment or job insecurity. One in five also answered that wars, pandemics, political issues and climate change are decisive issues.

In Italy weighed down by absent or unstable work

Italy's position is striking, where the first cause of lack of satisfaction, present or future, of the desire to have children is indicated in work: 30% of respondents report it. Worse than us are only Thailand and South Africa with 33%. This is followed, with 29%, by income-related constraints, and concerns related to the context, including conflicts, climate and uncertainties in the geopolitical framework. The housing problem is felt less, by 14% of the respondents.

The alarm over the "loneliness epidemic"

.

The same share of 14% admits difficulties in finding a suitable partner, perfectly within the general average of all countries. This average drops to 11% when the lack of cooperation of partners in home and childcare is named as the cause. In Italy it is just 8%. But women everywhere still perform three to ten times more unpaid domestic work than men. Inequalities and imbalances are "silent determinants that hinder the achievement of fertility goals". Economic precarity and backwardness on the path to gender equality are contributing, according to the report, to an 'epidemic of loneliness' that affects fertility rates.

The real fertility crisis

.

The picture drawn explains the report's title: the fertility crisis should not be read as a problem of under- or overpopulation, but as a manifestation of the impossibility of exercising reproductive autonomy. Birth rates are falling not because of women or young people 'no longer wanting to have children', as simplifications would have it, but because people are unable to have the families they want. They fail because of the high cost of living, sexist discrimination and uncertainty about the future. These are the main barriers to parenthood for millions of people around the world, including Italy.

Away with one-off bonuses and ineffective bans

What to do, then? Make it binding when the international human rights conventions guarantee that people have the right to "choose, freely and responsibly" the number of daughters and sons and when to have them. No other person can make these decisions in their place. On one point, the report is blunt: policies aimed at influencing fertility rates are largely failing. Ineffective actions taken by many governments include financial incentives such as one-off baby bonuses, bans on sexuality and affectivity education in schools, criminalisation of access to abortion, and restrictions on access to contraception. Measures considered counterproductive, because they worsen the problem they seek to solve and can lead to unintended consequences. Abortion alts, for example, are linked to an increase in the number of unsafe terminations of pregnancy and higher maternal mortality, not to mention that unsafe abortions are a major cause of secondary infertility. Limiting choices and opportunities can also make young people more pessimistic about their future and less inclined to have children.

The recipe: act on rights, from labour to housing

UNFPA's thesis is that we must stop trying to 'fix' birth rates and instead focus on rights-based solutions, with an approach that includes affordable housing, decent jobs, assisted reproduction for all people, not just the wealthy, policies that facilitate families, such as parental leave, equal rights and recognition of different types of families. In short: putting people in a position to exercise their reproductive autonomy. With the long view of youth and not the short view of short-breathed politics that only thinks about the next election. As one young activist said in response to a UNFPA questionnaire, 'young people do not only think about their future children, but also about the world that these children will inherit'.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti