Neil Young, McLuhan and the 'Dune' movies: how much Canada is in US culture!
Trump plays with duties in Ottawa and the 51st state boutade, but more than once Canada has conquered the US. With music, literature and film
5' min read
Key points
5' min read
Wax on, wax off. Put on the duties, take off the duties. Then put them on again, then off again: it would take Master Miyagi from Karate Kid to trace a modicum of balance in Trump's trade policies towards Canada. Or perhaps a robust dose of lithium, the mood stabiliser most favoured by America's desperate housewives. But the concept that, between the serious and the facetious, 'The Donald' wants to get across in the end is simple, very simple: dear Canadians, either you join us and become the 51st of the United States of America or it will be total trade war, with tariffs.
There is a bit of the doctrine of Manifest Destiny behind it, which in the 19th century wanted Americans to expand by exporting their values throughout the New World, a bit of the boorish stadium chorus 'We are the strongest/ but who the f... are you'. There's a bit of the snootiness of those who consider their neighbour some kind of poor relation who, if he ever has the honour of being invited to dinner, would do well to put on his best suit and look his best. Yet.
Yet the thing Trump does not know or pretends not to know is that the culture of his much-loved United States is deeply indebted to Canada; that the maple leaf flag has given the American cultural industry some of its best minds; that Canadian soft power has more than once conquered the US. With music, film, literature. Let's look into it.
The Band, Bob Dylan's 'boys'
.It is obligatory to start with popular music, the first artistic field in which the United States has demonstrated its exceptionality to the world. There is only one musical artist in history to have won the Nobel Prize for Literature: it is Bob Dylan, a Jew from Duluth, Minnesota. But what for a good decade was his band - or rather: The Band, as if it were the band par excellence - was four-fifths Canadian citizens: Rick Danko, Garth Hudson, Richard Manuel and of course the immense Robbie Robertson. Without him we would not, for example, have had that masterpiece called The Night they drove old Dixie Down, the finest song about the War of Secession ever written. Written from the perspective of Southerners, to be precise, a detail that many Trump voters should also cherish.
A Giant Named Leonard Cohen
.We said Bob Dylan, but Canada too has had its Bob Dylan: Leonard Cohen, novelist lent to songwriting. He too is Jewish, but from Montreal, Quebec, a cosmopolitan attitude, the personal and the political coming together, the Buddhist faith winning out over everything. Poignant ballads like Suzanne and So Long Marianne bear his signature, not to mention Hallelujah, a song that is now performed more often at weddings than Schubert's Ave Maria.


