The first school welfare index is now online: a report taking stock of facilities and services
Italia split in two: schools in the provinces of Bergamo, Sondrio and Savona top the rankings, whilst those in the South bring up the rear, with Sicily at the very bottom. The index was launched today in the Senate during the presentation of educational projects by the InClasse platform. Nineteen indicators were examined, relating to three areas: services, energy and transport.
Bergamo is the Italian province which, on average, has more infrastructure and services available in its schools than the rest of Italia. Trapani, on the other hand, comes last. This is confirmed by the first school welfare index, launched today by the InClasse platform during the event ‘Roots for the Future: 5 years of educational projects by the Fondazione Articolo 49’. The index analysed state schools in 104 Italian provinces, from primary to upper secondary level, and is available online on the InClasse platform’s website.
Indicators
The Index, which was developed with the aim of summarising, in a single figure, certain characteristics of the infrastructure and services available in schools across Italy’s various provinces, is based on 19 indicators falling into three main categories: services, energy and transport. The ‘services’ dimension comprises seven indicators: the presence of a canteen, a sports hall, an auditorium, computer rooms, technical classrooms, communal areas and spaces designated for teaching. The ‘energy’ dimension also comprises seven indicators: measures to reduce energy consumption; double glazing or double-skinned windows; roof insulation; external wall insulation; zoning of the heating system; solar thermal systems; and photovoltaic systems. Finally, there are five indicators for the transport dimension: availability of urban public transport, inter-city public transport, rail transport, transport for students with disabilities and the presence of cycle paths. The report was produced as part of the thesis, currently in the process of being published, ‘Measuring school welfare in Italian provinces: construction and analysis of a composite indicator for the five-year period 2020–2025’ by Claudia Lazzaro, a student on the Bachelor’s degree programme in Statistical and Economic Sciences at the University of Milan-Bicocca.
The overall standings
In the overall ranking, which represents an average of all available infrastructure and services, the province of Bergamo tops the list, with an index of 52.7 out of a maximum score of 100. The Lombardy province’s ranking is in fact the result of its 3rd place in the Transport sector, 4th place in the Energy sector and 32nd place in the Services category. Rounding off the top three are Sondrio (52.2) and Savona (50.4). Also in the top ten are Ravenna (50.1), Parma (49.5), La Spezia (49.4), Como (49.3), Ascoli Piceno (49.3), Prato (48.8) and Lodi (48.4). The highest-ranked of the major provinces is Venice (21st place), followed by Bologna (24th), Turin (28th), Genoa (31st) and Rome (33rd). The province of Milan ranks only 48th in the overall standings, just above Florence (49th), whilst Naples is in 98th place. At the very bottom of the table, however, are Crotone (with an index of 29.4), Reggio Calabria (29.3) and Trapani (27.8).
Services
If we analyse the ‘Services’ category – which includes canteens, gyms, auditoriums, IT and technical classrooms, and communal and teaching spaces – the ranking changes. In this case, Prato and Genoa are joint top with an index of 65.5, whilst the province of Massa-Carrara completes the podium with 64.5. In this ranking, Milan performs well in 7th place (index 63.2) and Florence in 9th with 62.7. Once again, the Centre-South performs very poorly, with Latina in last place (40.2), preceded by Cosenza (40.3), Crotone (40.4) and Palermo (40.7).
Energy
The data for the ‘Energy’ category include factors such as reduced energy consumption, the presence of double glazing, wall and roof insulation, and the use of solar and photovoltaic systems. In first place is the province of Sondrio (index of 53.9), followed by Rieti (52.4) and Vicenza (51). The top ten also includes a city from the south (Lecce, in eighth place). Bringing up the rear is Trapani (index of 10.8), preceded by Livorno (13.3) and Reggio Calabria (14.3).
Brand connect
Newsletter Scuola+
La newsletter premium dedicata al mondo della scuola con approfondimenti normativi, analisi e guide operative
Abbonati

