Public television

Rai: talk of a licence fee cut resurfaces, with opposition now off the table

An amendment tabled by Forza Italia to the public service reform paves the way for a reduction in the licence fee, whilst providing for compensation from other public funds.

 IMAGOECONOMICA

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

The Rai licence fee may be reduced. The funding for Rai, however, will not. It is around this distinction that a political – and, above all, financial – battle is reigniting in the Senate, one that has accompanied the public service for years.

The issue has been brought back to the table by an amendment to the RAI reform tabled by the rapporteurs Claudio Fazzone and Roberto Rosso, both of Forza Italia. The provision introduces a safety net: should licence fee revenue fall, Rai must receive corresponding public funds so that its funding is not reduced. It is this provision that once again makes it possible to discuss a reduction in the licence fee without simultaneously creating a shortfall in the organisation’s accounts.

Loading...

Rosso directly links the proposal to the European Media Freedom Act. The amendment, he explains, is ‘fully in line with the provisions of the European EMFA Regulation, which stipulate the stability and predictability of the resources allocated to public service broadcasting’. He adds that ‘in the event of any reduction in licence fee revenue, funding for public service broadcasting should be guaranteed through the transfer of equivalent public resources’.

That is precisely the point. At present, the amount of the licence fee can be adjusted annually by the Government, without any reduction automatically triggering compensation. Following the integration of the licence fee into electricity bills, in 2024 the licence fee was reduced from 90 to 70 euros and Rai received additional funding, but without any automatic mechanism enshrined in law. The new mechanism, on the other hand, aims to transform this compensation into a structural guarantee.

A solution that immediately reignites the debate within the majority. The Lega, which has long made the licence fee cut one of its key causes, claims the initiative and welcomes Forza Italia’s overture: ‘We therefore note with satisfaction that Forza Italia has finally joined the Carroccio in the battle to cut the licence fee’. However, Lega MPs on the Supervisory Committee point out that ‘the licence fee reduction must be real, tangible and sustainable, achieved through greater efficiency at RAI, cost containment and increased revenue, without merely shifting the burden from one pocket to another among the public’.

And it is precisely this last point that the opposition’s criticism centres on. Because if citizens pay less through the licence fee and the State has to make up the shortfall through general taxation, it is the route by which the money comes in that changes, not necessarily who ultimately funds it.

Three members of the RAI Board of Directors – Alessandro Di Majo, Davide Di Pietro and Roberto Natale – also question whether the proposal is consistent with the spirit of the EMF. In their view, even with the compensation, ‘there is a risk that Rai’s funding will become more exposed to political discretion and the short-term demands of public finances’. They point out that the European regulation, on the other hand, calls for ‘adequate, sustainable and predictable financial resources’ for public service broadcasters.

Barbara Floridia, an M5S senator and former chair of the Supervisory Committee, was even more forthright: “The majority are already preparing to trumpet the so-called abolition of the Rai licence fee. Let us make this clear to the Italian people straight away: it’s a ploy. We’ll still be the ones footing the bill anyway.” The M5S proposal is different: to abolish the licence fee, but to link Rai’s funding to the ten-year term of the concession contract, thereby removing it from the annual negotiations on resources.

The opposition parties have also drawn up a series of sub-amendments. One, signed by Francesco Boccia, Antonio Nicita and Floridia herself, amongst others, stipulates that the entire revenue from the licence fee – with the exception of the portion allocated to the Fund for Pluralism and Innovation in Information – should go to Rai and that these resources ‘shall not be subject to any reduction’. Also on the table is the proposal for a progressive licence fee, determined by AGCOM and linked to tax returns.

Finally, the debate over the licence fee is intertwined with another ongoing issue concerning Rai: the re-establishment of the Supervisory Commission following the resignation of its members. The deadline set by the President of the Senate, Ignazio La Russa, for the parties to put forward their nominations is drawing to a close, whilst the reform enters the most delicate stage of the parliamentary process.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti