To the Senate

Rape Bill, text approved by majority without 'consent' and with more sanctions: controversy erupts

This text, according to rapporteur Bongiorno, 'goes one step further than the one' unanimously approved in the House last November, with the pact between Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni and Dem secretary Elly Schlein

by Rome Editorial Staff

2' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

2' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

A new version for the bill on sexual violence. The Senate Justice Commission has approved a new text proposed by the Lega Nord rapporteur Giulia Bongiorno.

In addition to her, the centre-right voted in favour; while the oppositions, from the Democratic Party to the Green Alliance and the Left, were against and critical.The total vote, in the end, was 12 yes and 10 no.

Loading...

Bongiorno: 'Turning point for women'

'My text,' Bongiorno said before the vote, 'puts the woman's will at the centre, it does not create any reversal of the burden of proof. For the first time in Italy, when there is neither consent nor dissent, there is a presumption of dissent in so-called freezing cases. So a breakthrough in favour of women. Those who say otherwise, in my opinion, should perhaps reflect'.

Not only that, because for the Senator 'this text is a step forward compared to the one' approved unanimously in the House last November, with the pact between Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni and Dem secretary Elly Schlein.

Increasing penalties

In the new text, there is an increase in penalties from 7 to 13 years' imprisonment in cases of sexual acts with violence, threats and abuse of authority (in the first version, penalties ranged from 6 to 12 years). Furthermore, from 6 to 12 years for those committed against the will of the victim (in the first version they ranged from 4 to 10 years).

The previous controversy

Just a few days ago, the text was changed by Bongiorno on the issue of 'consent'. In particular, that 'the sexual act is contrary to the person's will even when it is committed by surprise or by taking advantage of the person's inability, in the circumstances of the case, to express his or her dissent'.

A way of overcoming the miscontent of some centre-right exponents, according to whom the formula 'free and current consensus' was too vague and, therefore, subject to too many interpretations.

The protests

Protests today insist on that amendment. 'Without consent it is rape' read the protest signs in front of the main entrance to the Senate after approval. In addition to the protesters, politicians were also present.

From the PD, Michela Di Biase, rapporteur of the text unanimously approved in Montecitorio, said that Bongiorno 'presented and also voted for an amendment that totally undermines the proposed law on consent, already unanimously approved in the Chamber, and which, by transposing the Istanbul Convention, would have represented a leap forward for Italian legislation, bringing it into line with that of many other countries that have already done so. The text of the amendment was written by a woman but dictated by the patriarchy'.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti