Court of Cassation

Roggero acted with intent; he shot at the fleeing robbers to take the law into his own hands

The grounds on which the Court of Cassation dismissed the jeweller’s appeal have been filed, making the 14-year and nine-month sentence final

Mario Roggero al suo arrivo nel carcere di Bollate a Milano, 17 luglio 2026.  (ANSA/Mourad Balti Touati)

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

Mario Roggero acted with malice aforethought, shooting at the fleeing robbers and hitting them in vital areas with the intention of taking the law into his own hands. The Court of Cassation sets out in 34 pages the reasons for the judgement with which, last July, it dismissed the appeal by the 72-year-old jeweller from Grinzane Cavour, thereby making the sentence of 14 years and 9 months for the killing of two robbers and the wounding of a third, following a robbery at his shop, final. The Court of Cassation had upheld the request of the Attorney General’s Office and rejected the defence’s appeal. According to the Supreme Court, the forensic and ballistics reports indicate intent to kill: the first shot was fired from a distance of about half a metre, after which he moved and fired, with his arm outstretched, at two robbers who were ‘bending down’ as they were getting into the car in which they intended to flee. The possibility that “the robbers, intent on fleeing with the loot, might have changed their minds and returned to the jewellery shop to endanger the safety of those inside is, according to the appellant, based on purely hypothetical scenarios, devoid — as the Supreme Court judges point out — of any factual basis and whose plausibility is refuted by the fact that the stolen goods had already been seized and by the proximity to the getaway car”. According to the judges of the Court of Cassation, therefore, “the intent to murder was inferred, on the basis of an assessment firmly grounded in the findings of the preliminary investigation and free from any manifest illogicality or contradiction, from the rapid succession of multiple gunshots, fired at chest height and from close range, in the direction of the victims”. The acceptance of the fatal outcome in terms of foreseeability, in the judges’ view, “precludes the requested reclassification of the charges as manslaughter or unintentional homicide, to which such a subjective element is alien”.

No current danger

It is difficult to accept the argument that the fear of a danger still perceived as present. Nor does the defence’s account hold water, according to which Roggero feared for his wife’s safety, given that he had actually collided with her – pushing her aside – as he left the shop to chase the robbers. Also of significance are the statements made by the defendant to the press immediately after the events, which are admissible in court because they were given voluntarily to the media. These statements reveal that the jeweller, who had been the victim of other robberies without the perpetrators being adequately punished, believed that the State was unable to deliver justice to the victims of these crimes. It was the defendant himself who, in interviews given after the incident, stated that the action he had taken was the only way to stop the robbers and bring them to justice.

Loading...

Impulsivity in critical situations

The defence’s objection regarding the admission and use of the judgement by which, in 2007, Roggero had been sentenced to two years’ imprisonment, commuted to a fine, for insult and threats aggravated by the use of a weapon against his daughter’s ex-boyfriend and the latter’s parents. Testimony from the victims revealed that the jeweller had gone to the young man’s home armed with a weapon after learning that the young man had slapped his daughter. Circumstances which the Court of Cassation, having legitimately assessed them in line with the psychiatric report, deemed to be ‘a symptomatic indication of impulsivity when dealing with critical situations’.

From a strictly legal point of view, the Court of Cassation reiterates, on the subject of self-defence, what has already been stated on several occasions. Even in cases of putative self-defence, the defence is applicable only in the event of a risk – whether real or perceived – the latter assessment having to be made on the basis of the situation prior to the contested reaction. And this criterion remains unchanged even in the case of defence against trespass on one’s home: it is lawful only if there is an present danger. Which, in this specific case, the judges held, had by then passed.

Copyright reserved ©

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti