United States

Shapiro forced to apologise for his past positions on the Palestinians. Harassment allegations against his adviser also weigh heavily

Favourite as Kamala Harris's deputy faces criticism from when he was in his twenties

Articolo aggiornato il 4 agosto 2024 alle ore 10:19

Aggiungi Il Sole 24 Ore
ai preferiti su Google
Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro delivers remarks at a bill signing event at Cheyney University, an HBCU in Cheyney, Pennsylvania, U.S., August 2, 2024.   REUTERS/Bastiaan Slabbers

3' min read

3' min read

Josh Shapiro, the governor of Pennsylvania, one of the finalists for the vice presidential nomination of Kamala Harris, the Democratic candidate against Donald Trump, faces criticism over his past positions on the Palestinians expressed when he was a university student. In an article - writes Haaretz - he criticised the Palestinians for being 'too aggressive' to achieve peace, and claimed to have volunteered in the Israeli army.

In this 1993 article for the University of Rochester's Campus Times, entitled 'Peace Not Possible', a 20-year-old Shapiro expressed deep scepticism about the Palestinian leadership of Yasser Arafat, whom he described as a divisive and power-hungry figure.

Loading...

Shapiro argued that the Palestinians were too internally fragmented and combative to create a peaceful homeland or coexist with Israel. He doubted the success of the peace plan, believing that the Palestinians would eventually demand more land and that true peace required education and communication, not territorial concessions. Despite his pessimism, Shapiro hoped for the success of the peace plan.

At the end of the article, Shapiro's biography stated that he 'spent five months studying in Israel and volunteered in the Israeli army'.

Shapiro's team was quick to distance itself from these allegations. When asked for clarification on the nature of this volunteer service by the Jewish News Syndicate, Shapiro's spokesman Manuel Bonder downplayed the claim and said that when Shapiro was in high school, he had volunteered on a kibbutz in Israel as part of a project.

"He worked on a farm and in a fishing business. The programme also included volunteering in projects at an Israeli army base. He was never engaged in any military activity,' Bonder added.

Asked about the article, Shapiro replied: 'Something I wrote when I was 20 years old? ... I was 20 years old." He emphasised his support for the two-state solution, saying, "I have said for years, long before 7 October, that I support a two-state solution, with Israelis and Palestinians living peacefully side by side, able to determine their own future."

While Governor Shapiro emerges as a leading contender for the vice presidential nomination, his views on the war have aroused spirited opposition from pro-Palestinian groups. Shapiro compared the transgressions of pro-Palestinian protesters to those of white supremacists and the KKK. He also called for the disruption of a pro-Palestinian camp at the University of Pennsylvania. Shapiro argued that 'peaceful protests cannot be an excuse for anti-Semitism'.

Despite his public pro-Israel stance, Shapiro has been openly critical of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, calling him in January 'a dangerous and destructive force' and 'one of the worst leaders of all time'. The Palestinian newspaper Quds News Network also wrote: 'Shapiro commented on Vice-President Kamala Harris's remarks on the war in Gaza, agreeing that he was right in pointing out the suffering of innocent people in the region'.

This has not allayed the fears of pro-Palestinian groups in the US, who criticise Shapiro's stance on campus protests and argue that they might go so far as to not vote for Kamala Harris if she chooses Shapiro as her running mate.

Some argue that those who criticise Shapiro for his past views do so because he is Jewish and Zionist. Critics argue that Shapiro's military volunteer work - a five-week stint on a kibbutz, according to his spokesman - should put him out of the running. They also point out the inconsistencies of the other two favourites, Minnesota Governor Tim Walz and Kentucky Governor Andy Beshear. Beshear stated that the US should not publicly criticise Israel, and Walz was criticised for his stance on detachment from Israel. Of the three, Shapiro was the most openly critical of Israel.

But the controversy against Josh Shapiro does not stop there. Last September, Pennsylvania, of which he is governor, paid $295,000 to settle charges against Michaele A. Vereb, one of his closest aides, against whom an employee had pointed the finger for sexual advances and criticism she had been subjected to after rejecting him. According to reports in the New York Times, Vereb had held the post for six months after the allegations were leaked and only resigned after a copy of the complaint was published. Upon his release, Shapiro's office had described him as a person 'dedicated to serving' others. The National Women's Defense League asked the Harris campaign to investigate the case.

The vice-president announced her intention to reveal her decision on Tuesday during a rally in Philadelphia. A choice by Shapiro could potentially exacerbate tensions within the pro-Palestinian faction of the Democratic Party, further increasing tensions as the Democratic National Convention approaches in Chicago on 19 August.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti