The Budget Bill

Superbonus, exit tax and education: a new summit is on the cards, with changes on the way. Here’s how the budget could change

A ruling coalition summit is expected. The deadline for parliamentary amendments is Tuesday at 6 pm. Amendments are being considered regarding the exit tax and the 10-year credit spread. Trade unions are pressing for changes to the cuts to pension indexation

6' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

6' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

The first key meeting in Parliament is scheduled for Tuesday 17 November at 6.00 pm: this is the deadline by which MPs must table their amendments to the budget bill in the Chamber of Deputies’ Budget Committee. However, last week’s hearings and meetings with the social partners at Palazzo Chigi have already provided more than a few clues as to how the budget bill might change as it progresses through Parliament. The halt to cuts to schools, the amendment to the exit tax with a higher threshold, and the revision of the Superbonus to spread the tax credit over 10 years in order to limit its impact now appear to be firm points on which action will be taken.

The majority and the Government are hard at work, ready – according to parliamentary rumours – to take stock of the situation at a new political summit, pending the announcement of a date for the meeting. Maurizio Lupi, leader of Noi Moderati, says: ‘We will hold discussions within the centre-right to improve the situation and will work in Parliament to strengthen the revaluation of middle-class pensions ’. On the very issue of pensions, the trade unions continue to hope for responses that will make the cut in pension indexation less punitive. But the demands reaching the Government are varied. Starting with healthcare, where calls have been made to increase funding, though the regions are already warning about how to finance an increase of between 400 and 500 million euros: “It could not come from regional contributions, because the regions are already stretched to the limit.”

Loading...

The exit tax

Rather than the figures themselves (which are modest compared with the overall impact of a budget worth 26 billion), the exit tax has come under heavy fire, particularly from professionals who advise high-net-worth individuals. The measure set out in the 2027 Budget Bill aims to tax capital gains at 26 per cent for those who decide to move abroad. The measure would apply to individuals resident in Italia for at least 6 of the last 10 tax years, provided the total value of their financial assets is at least 800,000 euros. One of the issues highlighted is that the exit tax, as currently outlined, would be levied on the capital gains realised rather than on the amount actually received.

The criticism has struck a chord with the Government and the ruling coalition, who have indicated a willingness to amend the measure. Following a meeting with the social partners, the Minister for the Economy, Giancarlo Giorgetti, confirmed that the Government is working on the issue. The changes could be designed to make the measure – which is estimated to generate revenue of 3.37 million in 2027, rising to 6.74 million annually from 2028 to 2031 before falling back to 3.37 million in 2032, selective and capable of targeting only tax avoidance schemes. Hence the proposal to significantly raise the threshold for the total value of financial assets above which taxation applies, whilst also limiting the impact solely to cases of transfers abroad made for tax avoidance purposes. The idea is that the threshold could rise to 5 million euros, excluding young people and start-ups (the latter request had come from the Lega).

However, there are those – such as Forza Italia – who have identified three key measures as priorities. “Only assets accrued in Italia should be taxed,” stated Stefania Craxi, chair of the Forza Italia senators, “using the value of the assets at the time of arrival as a benchmark, as is already the case for businesses. The promise made to those who have opted for the scheme for new residents must be honoured, because a credible state does not change the rules midway through the game. And the scheme must be made fully European, with a full deferral for those moving to another EU country, without the 50 per cent advance payment or the guarantee – provisions which today risk being ruled invalid by the Court of Justice.”

The Superbonus

The aim of the Superbonus is to mitigate the impact of the requirement to spread tax credits over 10 years, as provided for in the draft Budget Bill for works in 2023. Confindustria President Emanuele Orsini has asked the Government to set up a working group to amend a measure that severely impacts businesses’ liquidity.

The possibility of action was hinted at by ANCE Director-General Romain Bocognani at the end of Friday’s meeting at Palazzo Chigi with businesses regarding the budget. Bocognani reported that Minister Giorgetti ‘said they are working on this issue, which is a very important one, as emphasised by everyone’. Possible solutions to define the scope of the compulsory deferral were suggested during parliamentary hearings by trade associations and professional bodies: the range of proposals extends from objective exclusions based on limits on the value of prisoners’ claims (aiming to safeguard small businesses and professionals) or subjective exclusions (which would also protect SMEs in this scenario), or by establishing a speculative mechanism that would trigger the compulsory deferral only for those who have purchased the debts at a value significantly lower than their face value.

The school

Instead, there appears to be a U-turn on cuts to school staff, which would have affected around 7,000 employees. Confirmation came from the Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni in a video posted on social media following the initial indications that emerged from the summit with the trade unions. ‘The Government has officially confirmed that it intends to withdraw the measure that had caused particular discontent in the education sector. However,’ Meloni clarified, ‘since facts matter more than controversy, I also want to reiterate that these were not cuts’. “To be clear,” Meloni added, “no teacher would have lost their job, no ATA staff member would have been made redundant, and no class would have been closed. The measure included in the budget began to bring staffing levels into line with actual pupil numbers, but only in relation to new recruitments that need to be made, because schools have lost almost 800,000 pupils over the last 10 years due to the fall in the birth rate.”

These were the comments made by the PD secretary Elly Schlein during the ‘Stati generali della scuola’ (National Education Forum) organised by her party on Sunday 15 November: “They have withdrawn the cuts to education; now we are waiting for them in Parliament to see what happens.” And on the subject of teachers, she added: “Paying teachers better is one of the first things we need to do, because our teachers are among the lowest-paid in Europe. If teachers are the first line of defence for democracy, we cannot underpay them.”

More resources for healthcare, say the regions: but not at our expense

Loading...

The Government is also looking into ways of securing additional funding, with a view to allocating it to those working in the National Health Service. According to what emerged from meetings with the social partners, consideration is being given to how to free up resources to be allocated to doctors and nurses.

Some estimates circulating have put the estimated additional funding at around 400–500 million, but the regions have already set a limit on how this is to be raised. When questioned by the Ansa news agency, Massimo Fabi, health committee coordinator for the Conference of Regions, made it clear that an increase of this magnitude ‘would still be patently insufficient’ and that the regions should not be asked to make a further sacrifice to provide the additional resources: ‘On the contrary, a viable solution – one that would also send an important political signal – would be to reallocate the 1.6 billion earmarked for vouchers for the over-75s to purchase healthcare services to the Health Fund; this sum would otherwise go towards funding the private healthcare sector.’

Trade unions continue to press for pension reforms

Following Friday’s meeting at Palazzo Chigi, the trade unions are continuing to press for action on the cuts to pension indexation. On leaving the summit, CISL General Secretary Daniela Fumarola highlighted a glimmer of hope: ‘We were told that they are continuing to look into the matter, and that they will also try to provide us with answers through the parliamentary process.’

UGL General Secretary Paolo Capone recalls having ‘expressed the hope that the minimum wage could be increased more than fourfold; Minister Giorgetti took note of this, and now we will see in the coming months whether this will be honoured’.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti