Electric cars

Tesla, European sales slump in April. Italy bucks the trend

Technical rebound on the stock exchange. In the meantime, speculation (so far denied) about Musk's departure is being discussed. Wedbush: 'We believe he will remain CEO for at least five years'.

by Alberto Annicchiarico

Il ceo di Tesla Elon Musk saluta il presidente degli Stati Uniti Donald Trump mentre assistono ai campionati NCAA di wrestling maschile a Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, Stati Uniti, 22 marzo 2025. REUTERS/Nathan Howard/File Photo

5' min read

5' min read

While Chinese rival BYD grinds out better months of the year one after the other (in April 380,000 units sold, +20%), clear and increasingly worrying signals are arriving from Europe for Tesla. In Sweden, one of the countries with the highest penetration of the electric car, last month's figures speak for themselves: only 203 new registrations, a drop of 80.7% compared to the same month last year. A setback that, albeit on limited absolute volumes, takes on powerful symbolic significance in a market that has often led the way in the electric transition.

In the stock market a rebound after the recent declines, here's why

On the stock exchange, the day offered a technical rebound of close to 4% after the recent bearish pressures, with possible re-covering of short positions. Analyst consensus remains positive overall: out of 92 analysts, the majority maintain a 'buy' rating, with a median target price of $293.17, close to current values. Moreover, Tesla is a heavyweight component in the US technology indices, and the US tech market showed signs of strength today.

Loading...

Returning to European market data, it is not just Sweden. Pending the German figure (which has been very negative in recent months), a very clear indication of the difficult time Elon Musk's company is going through comes from France, the continent's second largest market for electric cars. In April, Tesla, according to data from the manufacturers' association Plateforme Automobile, sold just 863 cars, a drop of 59.4% year-on-year and the worst result in two years. What is also impressive, however, is the collapse in the ranking of best-selling models: the Model Y, long the leader, slipped out of the top ten, stopping in eleventh place. Those who thought the arrival of the new Juniper version would mark a revival will have to think again. Model 3 was a no-show.

The weight of the political Musk

.

Faced with a slump of this kind, it is inevitable to think that, in addition to the dated range and initial delays on the production of the restyled Model Y (deliveries in Europe are expected to pick up in June), the increasingly divisive political positions of Elon Musk, whose support for the extreme right and Donald Trump has raised protests both in the United States and in Europe, are also weighing heavily. The French ranking is now dominated by domestic models: Renault places three cars in the top 10, with the new R5 leading both in April and in the cumulative first four months (11,454 units). This is followed by the Scenic and the Citroën e-C3, the latter still slowed down by production problems. There were only three foreign models in the top 10: two Germans (Vw ID.3 and Bmw iX1) and the Korean Kia EV3.

Further food for thought: while Tesla sales are collapsing, the French electric market as a whole is not in crisis. In April, Ev registrations grew by 2.78%.

In Denmark, another traditionally favourable market for electric cars, Tesla lost 67.2% compared to April 2024, stopping at 180 new registrations. In March, the drop had been almost identical (-65.6%).

Bad in Portugal, rebound in Norway

.

It was also bad in Portugal: -33% in April compared to the same month in 2024, to just 302 units, while all new registrations of light electric vehicles increased by around 32%, the Portuguese automotive industry association Acap said on Friday. In the first four months of the year, Tesla's sales in Portugal fell 26.7 per cent to 2,447 units, although this was only the second largest drop among car brands after Italy's Fiat, whose sales plummeted 36 per cent to 2,239 units.

The exception is Norway, another key market for electric cars (over 90% of new registrations). Sales were up 11.8% in April (976 vehicles) compared to the same month last year, according to the Norwegian Road Federation. This is a rebound after Tesla sold 3,808 cars in Q1 2025, down 25 per cent from 5,090 in the same period in 2024, compared to +42 per cent for the market.

Italy bucking the trend

In April, according to data published by the Ministry of Infrastructure and Transport, Tesla registrations in Italy grew by 29.28%, a very positive figure if it were not for the absolute figure of 446 cars. In contrast, however, with the data recorded in the rest of Europe. The increase in Italy follows the rise in March (+51.3%), the drop in February (-54.46%) and the +0.99% in January. However, the balance for the first four months of the year remains negative, with 3,916 registrations, down 3.67% compared to the same period in 2024. In the whole of 2024, the electric car giant's registrations were down 5.91%. A strong signal in Italy (thanks to the endothermic, however) came from the Chinese brand MG Motor, a group controlled by the giant Saic Motor: in April, it registered 5,488 cars (+50.56%, compared to the rise recorded in Europe with +48.6% in March and +33.5% in the quarter).

Cda, turmoil inside and out

The European context is made even more incandescent by the rumours - officially denied - about a possible replacement of Elon Musk at the helm of Tesla. The Wall Street Journal reported that the board (urged on by big investors - including Vanguard, BlackRock, Morgan Stanley, JP Morgan, Norges Bank - who are increasingly concerned) has reportedly initiated contacts with headhunting companies to evaluate alternatives. The chairman of the board, Robyn Denholm, denied everything, reaffirming 'full confidence' in the CEO. Musk, increasingly absorbed by political assignments and parallel projects, has long since shifted his focus from electric vehicles to futuristic promises: robotaxis, artificial intelligence, humanoid robots. The vision is there,the stellar multiples hold up despite the -30% drop in the share price since the beginning of the year (to $280 and 900 billion capitalisation), but sales are falling.

Is Tesla still Musk?

.

For some analysts there is no question, Tesla is Musk and Musk is Tesla: up to 75% of the stock market capitalisation would be linked to his figure and his bold bets. But the increased political polarisation, the lack of operations, the continuous announcements without tangible repercussions and the aggressiveness of new competitors, particularly from China (where sales in March went very well but those in April are said to have fallen sharply, according to rumours), are undoubtedly eroding the brand's position in the market. 'We believe Musk will remain ceo of Tesla for at least five years,' commented Wedbush's Daniel Ives, 'and we would be surprised if the board is still pursuing this path as of today. We continue to believe that Musk's days in the White House are coming to an end after this strong warning signal from the board'.

What will happen in the coming months

The coming months will be decisive. After a disastrous first quarter, with revenues down 20% and profits down 71%, investors and observers are waiting to see whether the European crisis is an isolated episode or the beginning of a structural trend. What is certain is that Europe, once a favoured market for Tesla, now seems to be turning its back on it.

The group is offering loan discounts and other financial incentives for new purchases in Norway, Sweden, Germany and the UK in an attempt to stimulate demand.

Tesla has to contend with increased competition from European manufacturers (the Volkswagen Group is well ahead in the registration rankings) and the entry of new Chinese players, especially BYD in the medium term.

'Tesla's technological advantage,' argues Andy Leyland, co-founder of SC Insights, 'has been largely eroded with the current model range, Competition will weigh on sales.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti