Automotive

Tesla, Musk back behind the wheel and the stock runs (despite disastrous accounts)

After the bad results of the first quarter, the tycoon will devote two days a week to political engagements. But according to Wedbush, his intemperances would 'jeopardise up to 10% of future demand'.

Il ceo di Tesla Elon Musk indossa un cappello “Trump aveva ragione su tutto!” mentre partecipa a una riunione di gabinetto alla Casa Bianca, 24 marzo 2025. REUTERS/Carlos Barria

4' min read

4' min read

Accounts down, share price up (+5.28%, to $250). This is nothing new for Tesla. It had happened recently, even after the previous quarterly report (+2.87%) at the end of January. Even less disastrous than the one presented on Tuesday. Of course, the first-quarter 2025 results are chilling: net profit plummeted 71% to $409 million year-on-year; group revenues (including services and energy) to $19.3 billion, -9%, against estimates of $21.4 billion. Minus 20% for automotive alone. Operating margin plummeted to 2.1% from 6.2% in the previous quarter. Deliveries down 32% over the previous three months and 13% year-on-year. "The magnitude is impressive: +82% peak performance between two quarters (between Q3 and Q4 2024), followed in less than three months by the steepest decline in a decade," notes Gabriel Debach, analyst at eToro.

The update of the Model Y (Juniper version, however, the fastest launch in the brand's history, according to Musk) is to blame, of course, but not only. The CEO has admitted that between tariffs, geopolitics on the roller coaster, boycotts and attacks on dealerships, demand is faltering. Now the bet is no longer on 2 million units delivered in 2025. On the contrary, the figure could be at or below last year's level.

Loading...

Musk returns to focus on Tesla

.

Yet, Wall Street has turned away. Why? Because Musk has promised to refocus on Tesla, limiting political outings related to the DOGE programme of cutting federal spending to a maximum of two days a week. Most of his time will be devoted to Tesla. It only takes a little, sometimes, to rekindle enthusiasm.

'The market,' comments Debach, 'seems to be looking beyond the numbers. Because while it is true that Tesla misses expectations, it is equally true that Musk continues to drive expectations like no other CEO in the world. Tesla, in fact, continues to trade on visionary equity multiples: expected price-earnings ratio at 89.7x, against 27x for Amazon, 20x for Meta and Nvidia, and 17x for Alphabet. Musk's strength, more than data'.

"Investors will probably breathe a small sigh of relief after Musk announced that he will step back from the DOGE project next month, which may reduce some of the pressure on Tesla's brand image," adds Chris Beauchamp, analyst at online trading platform IG.

"After a 50 per cent drop in the share price, the market is inclined to change its perspective and, with Musk ready to return to full Tesla management, there is a tendency to set aside recent fears in the hope that leadership will return firmly to his hands," adds Beauchamp.

L'utile di Tesla crolla: pesa il coinvolgimento politico di Musk

Analysts at Morningstar agree: "We believe the market was concerned that Musk might be too distracted to effectively lead Tesla, at the risk of damaging the brand. His decision to reduce involvement as an advisor should help allay these fears'.

Four Pillars for Rebirth

The narrative holds for now, thanks to four pillars: robotaxis coming in June, booming energy business (+67% year-on-year), a new, more affordable Model Y approaching, and the Optimus robot planned for 2025. In addition, Musk changes course: he now talks about 'sustainable abundance' and puts AI and robotics at the centre.

But there is no shortage of technical warning signals. On 14 April, the thirteenth death cross (a term used in technical analysis to indicate a major bearish signal) for Tesla, with the stock down 39% from its January highs: the worst quarterly fall ever. And this time it is not just a technical fact. The problems are real: compressed margins, factories to upgrade, global uncertainties.

Political Musk damage to the brand: permanent?

"The damage to the Tesla brand caused by Musk's outbursts in the political arena and with DOGE will not go away overnight," notes Dan Ives, an analyst at Wedbush, one of Tesla's biggest 'fans'. "We estimate that this may have compromised up to 10 per cent of future demand, especially in Europe and the US. But it was necessary to close a dark chapter to open a new, brighter one focused on innovation and technology. Musk is Tesla, and Tesla is Musk. And this is one of the most important moments, in terms of technological advances, in the company's history.

In June, Ives reminds us, the launch of unsupervised full autonomous driving is expected in Austin, Texas, where Tesla is based. A low-cost model will arrive in 2025 (an entry-level Model Y with cheaper materials and equipment that should compete with the many more affordable Chinese SUVs). In 2026, large-scale production of the Cybercab (Tesla's robotaxi) will start in the US, and the Optimus project (the humanoid robot that will have a sales impact '10 times greater than any product launched in the past', according to Musk's statement a month ago) 'becomes more and more concrete'.

Wedbush raised its price target again from $315 to $350 after the call on the first quarter accounts (it had lowered it from $550 to $315 on 6 April due to the entry into force of US duties, ed.), in the mid-range of market estimates, which range between $125 and $700.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti