Previews

'The Boys of Dungeon Lane', the review: Paul McCartney seeks lost time

Macca's 20th solo album is a tribute to Liverpool, John, George, Ringo and the world before the Beatles. What is genius in senility

by Francesco Prisco

Paul McCartney ad Abbey Road, durante il pre-ascolto di «The Boys of Dungeon Lane»

4' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

4' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

If Paul McCartney had wanted to splurge, he would have titled his 20th studio album In Search of Lost Time, just like the English edition of Marcel Proust's masterpiece, A Search for Lost Time. But, while he could afford it, he is not the type: he chose The Boys of Dungeon Lane, the reference to a half-gravel lane in Speke, the Liverpool neighbourhood that is home to the airport now named after John Lennon and in the 1950s was the terrain of the four's raids.

We've said it before and we'll say it again: the album to be released on 29 May, listened to and re-listened to in preview, is a work of senility, a kind of concept album that follows the vertical axis of the author's life, where each song sounds like a snapshot of Paul's life, but also of John, George and Ringo before the Beatles. It is as if, at the age of 84, Macca - the melodic and calculating soul of the Fab Four - was moved to tears as he thought back to the first 20 years of his existence, the only ones in which he was an ordinary person, the kind who can move freely in the streets, without legions of fans cheering you on and tinted-glass cadillacs waiting for you. The Boys of Dungeon Lane then takes post-World War II black and white Liverpool and makes poetry of the little things.

Loading...
Loading...

It starts with the dissonant rock of As You Lie There, Paul's first track recorded with Andrew Watt, a producer who specialises in shining the fur of old rock lions: it is a portrait of a teenager struggling with his first falling in love, between dreams and insecurities. One exotic guitar chord, built one finger at a time, and the atmosphere of the record is already clear. On drums, in the specific circumstance, is Chad Smith of the Red Hot Chili Peppers, one of the few feats on an album that - like McCartney I, II and III - remains almost entirely played by McCartney. Last Horizon is a reprise of an old track from Macca's corpus that for a thousand reasons had never been recorded and now sounds damn Brit Pop. How true that without the Fab Four there would be no Brit Pop.

And here we come to the ballad Days We Left Behind, from which the title verse of the album is taken: undoubtedly the best track on the album, with Paul's voice breaking as he remembers his friendship with John, their meeting at Forthlin Road, the McCartneys' home. We are in the neighbourhood of Early Days, another (remarkable) ballad of Lennonian reminiscences that Paul churned out in 2013. In the former as in the latter, those who grew up with their poster in their bedroom can't help but be moved. From the loving rock song Ripples on a pond we move on to the Mountain top experiment, a psychedelic picture of a girl getting high on a hallucinogenic mushroom at Glastonbury amidst electric guitar feedback and pitchy vocals, proof that Uncle Paul is losing his hair but not his taste for experiments.

Loading...

Down South is the album's second Beatlesian homage, this time dedicated to Harrison: a minimalist track (vocals, acoustic guitar and nothing else) that evokes a hitchhiking adventure with George down Chester Road, a truck stop destination. Southwards, between dreams of rock 'n' roll and the discovery of Twist and Shout.We two is a pretty love song with an unmistakably Sixties flavour recorded on a four-track Studer, like A Day in the Life, Come Inside a tight rock built on a distorted riff, Never Know a tribute to the Laurel Canyon scene with lots of flutes and guitars recorded backwards, like in the good old days.

Home to Us, feat. by Ringo Starr but also by Chrissie Hynde and Sharleen Spiteri on backing vocals, is another postcard sent from 1950s Liverpool, the working-class ship-building city: as a place, it must not have been much, but 'for us it was home'. Another unforgettable moment on the album. A delicate, acoustic pop song is Life can be hard, a track written during the pandemic that recalls the atmosphere of Flowers in the Dirt, while First Star of the Night is an intimate ballad about certain days when you feel it raining inside.

Loading...

The journey backwards in The Boys of Dungeon Lane ends with Liverpool before McCartney: in Salesman Saint the dedication is to Macca's parents and the jazzy flavour of the songs the couple loved to dance to emerges (there is also the trumpet, an instrument played by Daddy Jim). Momma Gets By is a work of fiction: it offers a portrait of a woman who married a layabout and goes out of her way to get by.

The Boys of Dungeon Lane is imperfect and honest, because Paul's voice can no longer be that of Golden Slumbers, the years go by even for those who have been touched by the Lord, but greatness lies precisely in presenting oneself to the public as one is, in all one's fragility: without tricks. This one may not be McCartney's finest solo album (the 'competition', on the other hand, is impressive: from the three namesakes to Band on the Run) but it is the definitive album. An album that Macca made for himself, before he made it for us. And for that we will be forever grateful.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti