The EU Advocate General’s conclusions: digital platforms are not free
If the services are provided in return for payment, the issue of VAT arises once again: the Milan Public Prosecutor’s Office is seeking 1.4 billion
Key points
Are Facebook’s digital services free – as per the long-standing claim on the page featuring the blue-and-white logo – or do they in fact conceal a covert form of payment (where users’ personal data is handed over and used by the platform for advertising purposes)?
The case brought before the European Court by the Federal Union of German Consumer Organisations and Associations (C-643/25) appears set to have far more significant repercussions than the – already important – protection of consumers’ rights: underlying this is the issue of reciprocity of services, which would open the door to the tax authorities’ claims as set out in the investigations by the Milan Public Prosecutor’s Officeprecisely against Facebook/Meta, LinkedIn and X (formerly Twitter), amounting to 1.4 billion euros of alleged tax evasion.
The story
The German case stems from opposition to the claim that the service is free, with the Consumers’ Union arguing that Facebook is not actually free because users provide their personal data and consent to its use for commercial purposes in exchange for access to the social network. The German courts had dismissed the appeal, ruling that the ban on describing a service as free applies only in cases where consumers incur financial costs. This led to an appeal to the Federal Court of Justice, which referred the case to EU courts. Yesterday, the Advocate General in Luxembourg, Laila Medina, concluded that the disclosure of personal data and consent to its commercial use ‘constitute a form of payment within the meaning of the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive’. Therefore, the Advocate General states, a service cannot be classified as ‘free’ when consumers are required to provide such data for commercial purposes, unless it is processed solely to ensure the provision of the service or to fulfil legal obligations. Meta defends itself on this ground – which concerns allegedly unfair commercial practices – by arguing that the list of prohibitions set out in EU Directive 29 of 2025 is exhaustive, but it is clear that in this case the stakes are quite different.
Correspondence
If the Court of Justice of the European Union were to uphold Medina’s conclusions, the two opinions on the subject issued by the VAT Committee (Working Paper 958 of 2018 and WP 1118 of November 2025) would suddenly become digitally obsolete. Both opinions – although the more recent one did so in a more nuanced manner – had emphasised the lack of reciprocity in the services provided between the user and the platform ‘where services are provided on the same terms to all users of the platform, regardless of the quantity and quality of the data individually supplied, such that no direct link (direct link) can be established between the two services’. Reciprocity between services which, according to the Milan Public Prosecutor’s Office, nevertheless exists in the form of a barter transaction (Article 12 of Presidential Decree 633/1972).
Should the CJEU decide to uphold the Advocate General’s opinion and the accompanying grounds, this would forcefully reopen tax claims against the platforms, but this time at EU level.

