Luxury in China: the challenge continues, with the second-hand market and local brands also playing a part
Key points
- The issues to be resolved: ‘luxury shame’, the economic slowdown and cultural misunderstandings
- After a year of mixed fortunes, a slow recovery is on the horizon
- Aspiring customers are turning to local products
- Does buying second-hand jeopardise credibility?
- Brand investments: new openings, fashion shows and restructuring
In December 2019, luxury brands were preparing to close their financial year with one certainty: purchases by Chinese consumers – with the younger generations eager to make their mark and keen on luxury goods – would account for around 40 per cent of the luxury personal goods market within a decade (according to a Bain & Co. estimate at the time). At the same time – and this is now history – the first Covid-19 fatalities were being recorded in Wuhan, an event that would also help to alter the fortunes of the luxury market.
Issues to be resolved: ‘luxury shame’, the economic slowdown and cultural misunderstandings
By the end of 2026, the share of the Chinese market in the luxury goods sector had almost halved compared with what had been estimated at the time, and not solely because of the pandemic, which first brought travel to a sudden halt and then curtailed it: the Beijing government has imposed a ‘moralising’ crackdown on the ostentatious display of luxury goods; the bursting of the property bubble has reduced wealth and, consequently, purchases of goods that have become increasingly expensive due to upward pricing policies. Over the years, moreover, there have been a series of cultural misunderstandings between Western luxury brands and the Chinese consumer base: in June 2026 – to cite the most recent incident – the Chinese brand Molly Tea was fined for using a four-petalled floral motif that was too similar to Louis Vuitton’s monogram. The fine of 1.3 million – a hefty sum for the brand but a drop in the ocean compared with LVMH’s turnover (80 billion) – sparked a social media outcry, which may have had an impact on sales in the country: the French group recorded a 5 per cent decline in Asia-Pacific revenue in Q3 2026.
After a year of mixed fortunes, a slow recovery is on the horizon
Although analyses differ (Barclays’ European Luxury Goods team, for example, believes a significant recovery is unlikely in the short term), following a disastrous 2024 and a 2025 that will still be negative, 2026 could herald the long-awaited recovery of the Dragon: ‘The Chinese consumer is there and, even though the middle class is growing more slowly, the citizens of the People’s Republic are showing a desire to buy luxury and premium products,’ explains Federica Levato, senior partner at Bain & Co – “2026 was, however, a complex year: the first half went very well, whilst the second half saw a slowdown.” Several issues remain to be addressed: “Consumer confidence, in general, is at an all-time low and the Chinese economy, although its GDP growth rate is much higher than Europe’s, is slowing down,” continues Levato. “Then there is the ongoing crackdown on ‘excessive displays of wealth’, which is curbing socialising and spending.” In this context, companies must learn to engage with a consumer who is different from in the past: “Young, discerning, proud to be Chinese and therefore keen to buy local brands if they represent a viable alternative, as has happened in the automotive sector.”
Aspiring customers are turning to local products
Flavio Cereda, investment director for luxury brands at Gam, also believes in a moderate recovery, though he identifies some areas of weakness: ‘A moderate recovery in the Chinese market is expected by 2027, in the region of 1–2 per cent, but uncertainty remains regarding potential government measures: the tax on assets transferred offshore, introduced in July, has created a climate of uncertainty that could affect consumer confidence.’ According to Cereda, who is unequivocal, ‘without a recovery in China, the luxury sector will not return to pre-Covid average growth levels’; the ultra-wealthy ‘continue to buy, and indeed, VIP rooms and lounges are being expanded in Chinese shopping centres to offer a high-end shopping experience. However, they are still gravitating towards the same brands, to the detriment of others that are unable to regain the prominence they once enjoyed’.
Does buying second-hand jeopardise credibility?
The situation is different for aspirational customers: ‘They have been forced to switch to lower-priced products, and it is in these segments that local brands can compete with their Western counterparts’. In other cases, however, there is a risk of falling into a sort of self-cannibalisation: “The second-hand market is growing rapidly and, particularly for certain brands such as Chanel and Hermès, the price gap between a pre-owned item with an excellent rating and a new item has narrowed,” he notes. The same ‘boomerang’ phenomenon emerges in Barclays’ analysis, which highlights how ‘the increased professionalisation of platforms, product authentication, traceability and immediate availability are accelerating this market, putting further pressure on the prices of new goods’.
-U25574417060Jmh-1440x752@IlSole24Ore-Web.jpg?r=650x341)
