Festival of Economics 2025

Nobel Prize winner Robinson: 'US risks economic collapse'

For Nobel Laureate Robinson, Trump's immigration policies could block American growth based on innovation and inclusive society

by Laura La Posta

Aggiornato il 25 maggio 2025

4' min read

4' min read

Following verbatim the theory with which British-American academic James Robinson won the 2024 Nobel Prize in Economics, the Trump administration's policies risk leading the United States to collapse. This is because 'history teaches us that long-term growth is based on innovation, which can only develop in societies founded on inclusive institutions and policies'.

'It is too early to say whether the choices of the current American administration will lead the country to collapse, as happened to the Soviet Union and several African states,' Robinson argued at the Trento Festival of Economics. 'What is certain is that for decades the United States has been a magnet for new talent, it has consistently attracted the best minds; think for example of where Elon Musk or Steve Jobs' parents came from. Now a kind of antagonism is being created and this could create a disastrous problem, a loss of talent that could have a serious impact on American innovation and growth in the long term'.

Loading...

The alarm - with profound implications for the world economy - froze the large audience of students, lecturers and families in the room to listen to the economist in connection from his University of Chicago. Already in another panel, the director of Harvard Entrepreneurs and founder of Physis Investment, Stefania Di Bartolomeo, had expressed 'strong fears about the loss of democracy in the United States, more than about tariffs'.

The hope: pragmatic Trump will understand what he has done

.

The alarm, however, was diluted into a wishful thinking on the part of the economist. "Donald Trump is a pragmatic person and when he sees and understands the consequences of his actions and choices he may back down; however, it is difficult to predict now what he will do," Robinson said. For the time being, one has to take note of the "American institutional crisis", the "attack on liberal institutions, including universities" and the fact that basically Trump and his shadow advisor Elon Musk believe that a government does "more damage than anything else and so the more streamlined it is and the more it lets the private sector do, the better."

On the other hand, however, "Trump is a symptom of a deep and widespread malaise among Americans, which is very alarming: the inclusive institutions of the previous democratic administration have shown that they no longer work in the United States, that they do not bring widespread benefits," said the Nobel laureate. In the course of his lecture, the academic showed some thirty slides full of ad hoc elaborations for the Trento Festival of Economics, focusing on the graph showing "the disillusionment of 85% of Americans with the liberal democratic system, carried out by politicians who do not care what people think" and above all on the graph highlighting "the collapse of generalised prosperity in the US, where since the 1970s only those who have gone to university can expect to improve their income. "This is very serious," Robinson argued, "and is the basis for the success of the Make America Great Again mantra, which is in a sense a reaction to the lack of inclusion seen in recent decades and is a failure of inclusive institutions based on innovation.

But how could this happen, given that all of Robinson's studies of so many countries show that inclusive societies and institutions that drive innovation create increased generalised wealth? The Nobel Prize winner honestly acknowledges that he needs to update his theories, taking into consideration other aspects that have so far not been sufficiently analysed in the two books entitled "Why Nations Fail" and "The Bottleneck", written with Daron Acemoglu (who was awarded the 2024 Nobel Prize together with him and Simon Johnson and is today in Trento).

Musk and Trump? An ideological project

'The current political project in the US shows us that our theories are incomplete,' he said with unexpected humility. 'We have focused on the material levers that drive innovation and growth (e.g. the number of researchers and patents). But these elements in the current US administration are secondary, because the Trump and Musk project is largely ideological and is based on economic liberalism, radical 'libertarianism' and Maga nationalism. We will study these new variables'. After all, Robinson added, even 'China is showing that growth may not be accompanied, at least for a few decades, by greater inclusion and democratisation, and that 'extractive' and non-inclusive institutions can create development'. The last line of the slides reads "Where does all this end?". How will it end? Robinson left the answer unanswered and perhaps by the Festival of Economics 2026 he will have a few more clues to answer.

Digital inequalities and coup 'responses

Robinson also dwelt on two tense elements described in an interview with Il Sole 24 Ore, the technological impact on inequalities and the weight of coup d'états in sub-Saharan Africa. On the first front, responding to a question from our newspaper, Robinson explained that technologies such as artificial intelligence can increase inequality but 'it is a social choice: in Germany or Sweden Ia exists, but I don't feel that inequality is comparable to that of the 'Anglo-Saxon' world'. On the second, Robinson reiterated that the emergence of military juntas in the sub-Saharan region is an 'answer' to tired democratic institutions lacking legitimacy.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti