Centre-right

Three years of Meloni in power. Hers is the third longest government: balance sheet and prospects

The international press speaks of a new conservatism, difficult to pigeonhole between Trump's Maga excesses, the Lepenist right or Orbán's 'illiberal democracy'.

by Manuela Perrone

La Presidente del Consiglio Giorgia Meloni (Foto Mauro Scrobogna / LaPresse)

4' min read

4' min read

It is three years today since the general election that brought the right-wing Fratelli d'Italia to the government of the Republic for the first time. "Three years that seem like ten," commented from New York on 24 September, on the sidelines of the 80th UN General Assembly, the helmswoman of the turnaround: Giorgia Meloni, the first Prime Minister who now boasts the milestone of the third longest-lasting Executive in Italy, after Silvio Berlusconi's fourth and second, at least if we look at the actual days that in mid-September exceeded the 1,058 of the Craxi Government.

The return of the primacy of politics

.

The ballot box on 25 September 2022 marked the return of the supremacy of politics over the technical-institutional imprint of Mario Draghi's government, which lasted twenty months, just long enough to secure the Pnrr and relaunch the country after the darkness of the pandemic. The vote has rewarded Fdi, the only party, born from the ashes of the National Alliance and before that the MSI, which had remained in opposition during the Draghi era and which had never before risen to lead the country. Faithful allies, for now, are Forza Italia's Azzurri and the Leghists, led respectively by deputy prime minister Antonio Tajani and Matteo Salvini. Still weak is the opposition front, divided and competing: one of the factors of the premier's success and popularity so far.

Loading...

The path of prudence on public accounts

.

From the stage of a rally in Ancona a few days ago, Meloni listed the long series of disproved forecasts, from the spread 'at the lowest level in the last 15 years' to employment growing by about a million since October 2022, with the record rate ofemployment in the South. The utmost prudence has marked the management of the public accounts so far, also thanks to the cautious navigation of the Lega Nord Minister for the Economy, Giancarlo Giorgetti, who is very attentive to the perception of the markets in the presence of a public debt that remains among the highest in Europe and is expected to close 2025 just above 3,080 billion.

A stifling growth and the promise of energy price intervention

More disappointing are the results in terms of GDP: for 2025 and 2026, according to OECD estimates, it should stand at +0.6 per cent. The government forecasts +0.5 per cent for this year. The asphyxiated growth is weighed down by the dynamics of industrial production and energy prices: Meloni again acknowledged that 'they are an absolute priority' and promised a 'structural' intervention to lower them. Together with 'various initiatives to continue helping companies that invest and support their work: we are focusing on this for the budget law'.

International Clouds

.

The three-year period saw a drastic worsening of the international picture: the war in Ukraine was compounded by the Israel-Hamas conflict. And the advent of the second Trump presidency in the United States has further upset already precarious balances, forcing Italy into a complicated game of balancing acts. Meloni continues to mediate between the opposing positions of her deputies, i.e. between Tajani's no-ifs-and-buts Euro-Atlanticism and Salvini's pro-Russian impulses, who in turn is suffering the consequences of an increasingly 'vannaccizzato' party. Above all, the premier has decided never to distance herself from US President Donald Trump in the name of the unity of the West. Although the costs of the 15% tariffs agreement with the EU for our production system are all yet to be calculated.

The parachute metaphor

.

'Every day for me is a parachute jump,' Meloni had said in mid-July. An effective metaphor to represent the fatigue of governing in the storm. An effort that the Prime Minister hopes to see rewarded: she has already announced that she is ready to run again. And she trusts to cash in, first, at least some of the reforms put on track, starting with the justice reform on the separation of careers, which is moving at a fast pace towards final approval in Parliament to arrive at the referendum in the spring of 2026. The porting of the premierate and differentiated autonomy is less certain. But it is probable that a new electoral law will be brought to the polls in 2027.

"Europe's strong woman"

.

The international press does not stop analysing the Meloni phenomenon. Most recently the Express with its cover dedicated to "Europe's strong woman", and before that the Time ("Where Giorgia Meloni is leading Europe") and Le Figaro Magazine ("A liberal-populism at the service of Italy First"), most read Melonian politics as a new conservatism, difficult to pigeonhole between Trump's Maga excesses, Milei-style sovereignty, the lepenist nationalist right ofJordan Bardella or the 'illiberal democracy' of the Hungarian premier Viktor Orbán.

The immigration and security button

.

There is, however, one theme that unites all the Western conservative camps: the fight against irregular immigration, immigration that according to Trump's intervention-invitation to the United Nations 'will be the death of Europe'. It is this fight against human traffickers and the mantra of security that is the real trait d'union even of our own right wing, behind the government's most reckless initiatives. Like the opening of centres in Albania, so far more an expensive flop than a success, or like the Security Decree: the most identitarian manifesto implemented so far, with its calls against squatters, pickpockets and roadblocks that, for the whole executive, represent a formidable element to gather consensus.

Military expenditure and open questions

Between now and the next political elections, the government will have to overcome the Caudine forks of two budget laws constrained by the respect of the re-entry path agreed with the EU Commission and by the increase in military expenditure to which Italy has committed itself in NATO to reach +3.5% by 2035 (+5% also considering those for security). A goal that is also complicated by the Lega Nord 'no' to rearmament, by the protests of the opposition and by a public opinion frightened by the fear of a new world conflict. Faced with the growing aggressiveness of Putin's Russia, Meloni may be called upon to make far more radical choices than those taken so far. She is aware that she is walking on eggshells. But also that she does not want to jump without a parachute. If internal balances should ever become more tense, the hypothesis of an early vote will no longer be considered residual. We proceed one step at a time. The next objective is one: to win the regional elections in Marche, Veneto and Calabria. And to demonstrate that an alternative to the right-wing government is not yet in sight.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti