In the Spotlight

Tobacco taxes: the budget bill gathers pace whilst EU reform remains at a standstill

Whilst the revision of the European directive has stalled, the Budget Bill is moving forward in line with the EU Commission’s objectives on cigarettes, shredded tobacco, HTPs, e-liquids and pouches

 Nopphon - stock.adobe.com

4' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

4' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

Spain, which does not want to impose heavy taxation on loose tobacco, the kind used for roll-your-own cigarettes. Italia, which is defending the manufacturing sector and the supply chain for innovative smoke-free products. Sweden is standing firm on nicotine pouches. Finland is pushing to raise the minimum tax thresholds. When it comes to the taxation of tobacco and its ‘i’ and ‘smoke-free’ counterparts, the demands of EU countries also take into account the specific characteristics of their national markets.

The mosaic of the European single market did not come together at last week’s EU Council meeting: unanimity was only just missed (Malta voted against) and there were several expressions of displeasure over a draft revision of the TED Directive, which was, however, welcomed by, amongst others, the Minister for the Economy, Giancarlo Giorgetti. Meanwhile, in 2027, the Italian Budget Law will come into force, anticipating certain EU measures and raising revenue by revising its own timetable for price rises. This applies to cigarettes, cigarillos, loose tobacco, heated tobacco products (HTPs), e-liquids and nicotine pouches.

Loading...

Sachets and innovative products

Let’s take nicotine pouches, which are very widespread in Sweden and were the subject of debate at the Ecofin meeting on 9 November. The EU reform proposal provided for an initial minimum tax of 10 per cent of the price or 30 euros per kilo, to be increased over time to 50 per cent or 50 euros per kilo from 2032. At the meeting, a further (pointless) compromise was reached: a minimum levy of 20 euros per kilo (in line with the Swedish level) and new unanimous agreements on any future increases.

Pouches, such as liquids for electronic devices and solid tobacco-free inhalation products, are subject to consumption tax; whereas tobacco products (both traditional and innovative non-combustible products, such as heated tobacco) are subject to excise duty.

In Italia, specific regulatory requirements for sachets came into force this year, with the levy now set at 22 euros per kilo. The 2027 Budget Bill aims to introduce a requirement for distribution via authorised collection points throughout Italy.

In general, the budget does not announce any new tax increases for tobacco and alternative products, but brings forward to 1 July 2027 the increases that the previous Budget Act had already planned for the sector from 2028 onwards. Meanwhile, it is moving in line with the objectives of the European Commission, which is aiming for harmonised taxation within the single market, including for products that are alternatives to traditional ones. Traditional products currently account for 70 per cent of the volume distributed in Italia, down from 85 per cent in 2019.

“We support the EU’s modernisation of the taxation system for tobacco and nicotine products, through a harmonised approach to excise duties on nicotine pouches, inhalation products and heated tobacco products,” comments Andrea Di Paolo, vice-president of Bat Italia. ‘But it is essential that excise duties on these non-combustible products reflect their potential reduced risk profile compared to cigarettes.’

From cigarettes to e-cigarettes

For ‘standard’ cigarettes, under the Italian budget measures, the specific component of the excise duty remains fixed at 35.50 euros per thousand cigarettes until 30 June 2027 and rises to 38.50 from 1 July; the minimum tax burden, on the other hand, rises from 221 to 227 euros per thousand cigarettes. The technical report calculates that this increase will result, on average, in an extra cost of 13 cents per packet. However, the full effect will come from the two-stage increase scheduled for 2027; in any case, according to estimates, the impact on final prices could be between 40 and 50 cents per packet.

The European mediation text presented to Ecofin provided for a minimum threshold of 140 euros per thousand cigarettes from July 2028, set to rise to 170 euros from 2030 and to 200 euros from 2032. However, this included a deferral until 2036 for Italia and nine other countries (from Portugal to Greece), which, in order to meet the new levels, would have had to increase excise duties by more than 2.35 per cent per year on average compared with 2025. The same flexibility would have applied to shredded tobacco.

For this latter product, under the Budget Bill, the minimum excise duty in the second half of 2027 will rise by 4 euros per kilo (from 165.50 to 169.50). For heated tobacco, the excise duty rate will rise from 41 per cent to 42 per cent (based on an equivalent quantity of cigarettes). The same mechanism applies to e-liquids, whether nicotine-free or not: excise duty rates will remain at 20 per cent and 15 per cent until next June, before rising to 22 per cent and 17 per cent respectively. As for e-cigarette liquids, even those without nicotine, the amendment to the EU directive provides for the introduction, from 2028, of minimum excise duties set at 20 per cent of the retail price, or 20 cents per millilitre, with gradual increases until 2032.

Loading...

The impact on revenue and the market

The advance payment of taxes and excise duties (and therefore tax revenue) for 2027, as envisaged by the Budget Bill, is quantified as just over 112 million: 90.03 million for traditional tobacco (81.76 million for cigarettes alone), 12.71 million for heated tobacco and 9.45 million for e-liquids and flavourings. The draft also addresses the reorganisation of marketing procedures and establishes a mechanism for setting retail prices for e-liquids, a system previously reserved solely for manufactured tobacco products. Inclusion in the tariff and the retail price, as requested by the manufacturer or the exclusive importer, will be determined by Customs. Only those price components other than excise duty and VAT remain subject to free determination by the parties.

The tobacco and nicotine market has grown from 18.5 billion in 2019 to nearly 22 billion in 2025. This has been largely offset by a rise in cigarette prices, which has more than made up for the fall in volumes. Meanwhile, smuggling and unregulated sales are worth 1.2 billion euros and account for 690 million in lost tax revenue (source: Logista-Ipsos Doxa). Against the backdrop of all these fiscal measures, the usual doubts remain: the fear that a sudden increase in taxes and excise duties will drive consumers towards the black market. As the French and Greek cases have demonstrated.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti