Frontier Ethics

US and China seek digital sovereignty

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

Last week, Beijing banned its tech giants from buying Nvidia's downgraded Ia chips, such as the B40 and H20 series, mainly because accepting these downgraded versions would, according to comments in the 'South China Morning Post', mean accepting US-imposed technological inferiority and reinforcing dependence on American suppliers. Instead, the Chinese authorities are urging domestic companies to avoid buying these chips and are pressing them to justify any orders for foreign models over increasingly competitive local alternatives.

Beijing's response is part of a broader push for technological self-sufficiency and national security, which prioritises the development and adoption of domestic Ia hardware over dependence on intentionally limited foreign products. Recent US export controls, which ban high-end Ia chips but allow alternatives with lower specifications, have triggered a policy shift in China from tolerance of dependence to an urgent campaign for semiconductor independence.

Loading...

This position represents a turning point, shifting China's approach away from integration into global supply chains (led by the US) towards a long-term commitment to domestic technological capabilities and reduced dependence on US technology. Internationally, this sets the stage for accelerated decoupling in critical technology sectors as both the US and China move towards protectionism, with each side harnessing state power to promote domestic innovation and lock in technological dependencies.

China's refusal is not only due to technical or commercial considerations, but also to a clear strategic objective: to refuse to legitimise technological restrictions that would consolidate a position of subordination and redirect attention towards achieving technological sovereignty.

As Andrew Ng noted, China now believes it has made sufficient progress in the semiconductor sector to be able to chart its own course. Meanwhile, the US chip supply remains dangerously concentrated. Most of the cutting-edge nodes still come from Taiwan's TSMC. Even with the Arizona plant coming on stream, labour shortages and fragile supply chains mean that the US remains exposed to geopolitical shocks in one precarious geographic area. In the semiconductor sector, China is moving towards independence, while the US is faced with a single weak point: Taiwan.

If it is difficult for the US and China to achieve sovereignty, it is easy to imagine what it is like for the medium-sized powers: Europe's ASML has just bet more than $1.5 billion on France's Mistral AI to create a sovereign stack, but is still years behind in computing infrastructure, with data centre equipment delivery times now exceeding 100 weeks. Malaysia launched its first Ia chip with $6 billion of government support, but remains constrained by US export controls. Saudi Arabia is building 1.9 GW of data centre capacity and an Arabic-language AI, but must source all advanced chips from abroad. These nations are facing, to use a football term, an impossible trifecta: they lack the capital needed for a competitive infrastructure, the technical ecosystem to manufacture chips, and the geopolitical clout to ensure reliable supply chains. We are facing a problematic frontier: the window for significant sovereignty in Artificial Intelligence is rapidly closing, as computing requirements are becoming increasingly out of reach for non-superpower countries. In fact, compute, i.e. computing power and the use of digital technologies, is emerging as the greatest source of power in the 21st century. We witness a new challenge between Kratos and ethos. Kratos, in Greek mythology, represents the power of domination, the force that imposes itself and subjugates opponents, and in the philosophical and social context, Kratos becomes a symbol of political and authoritarian domination - naked power that rules and often stands in opposition to the reasons of ethics and justice. Ethos is the Greek term that over time has taken on the meanings of 'disposition', 'character', 'temperament'. In philosophy, ethos embodies the moral dimension, legitimacy, the ability to act according to shared principles and not only according to force. Ethics asks us to tame the digital Kratos by making it compatible with our democratic and economic structures.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti