2026 World Cup

When football is a dance between historical, political and cultural rivalries

Even in the quarter-finals of the North American World Cup, events on the pitch, disputes over independence and socio-economic tensions between countries are intertwined in an increasingly complex landscape of sports diplomacy

La semifinale dei Mondiali di calcio tra Francia e Marocco allo stadio Al Bayt di Al Khor, in Qatar, 14 dicembre 2022. (AP)

5' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

5' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

It is not unusual for certain sporting contests, particularly in team sports, to take on or acquire political significance. Take, for example, the Hungary v Soviet Union water polo match in Melbourne in 1956, when legend has it that the pool turned red from the intensity of the athletes’ contest, just a few weeks after Russian tanks had rolled into Budapest; the (in reality, very friendly) matches between Chinese and American table tennis players in Beijing in 1971, which heralded a period of Sino-American détente that would culminate in President Nixon’s visit to the Middle Kingdom; the 1976 Davis Cup final between Chile and Italia in Santiago, which the Azzurri contested (and won) despite it taking place at the Estadio Nacional, the scene of repression under Pinochet’s regime, which gained a boost to its image from the tennis event; the 1980 ‘Miracle on Ice’, the ice hockey match in which Team USA, made up of young amateurs, defeated the Soviet professionals at the Lake Placid Olympics; or, to limit ourselves to the most emblematic examples, the ‘Cricket for Peace’ initiative which, in 1987, saw the President of Pakistan, General Zia-ul-Haq, travel to India to watch a match of South Asia’s most popular sport (which, perhaps paradoxically, had been introduced there by the British Empire) and thus prevent the particularly heated tensions in the border areas from escalating into a full-scale war, possibly even a nuclear one.

Although the matches over the next few days do not carry quite such intense political significance, each one has a historical and even cultural significance that goes beyond mere footballing rivalry.

Loading...

Let’s start with France v Morocco, the first quarter-final to be played and also the one with the most tangible symbolic significance. From 1912 to 1956, the North African country was a protectorate, governed from Paris under the terms set out in the Treaty of Fez, signed ‘sight unseen’ by Sultan Moulay Abdelhafid. Although the French were not guilty of criminal acts against the population, unlike the Germans in Namibia or the Italians in Ethiopia, they constantly suppressed the independence movement; even an enlightened politician such as Foreign Minister Robert Schuman could, in 1951, defend before the General Assembly ‘the inalienable rights of France in North Africa’ and assert ‘the UN’s lack of jurisdiction over Tunisian and Moroccan issues’.

In 70 years of independence – during which the Lions of the Atlas have beaten Les Bleus only once, in a friendly in 1998 that was celebrated as a global triumph – economic ties have remained strong, particularly in terms of migration flows. Moroccans born in Morocco, numbering almost 1 million, represent the second-largest foreign community in France, after Algerians; those who have emigrated to France (including French nationals born in France) account for a third of remittances sent to the Kingdom of Morocco. Further strengthening bilateral ties, in addition to Moroccan players born and raised in France, there are subjects of Mohammed VI living in mainland France (notably the writer Leila Slimani) and French Jews born in Morocco, such as the musician David Guetta, the journalist Éric Fottorino and the film directors Éric Toledano and Olivier Nakache.

The Furias Rojas and the Diables Rouges have faced each other on several occasions, but the rivalry between Belgium and Spain is somewhat muted. Admittedly, there hasn’t always been love lost between them … but it’s been at least four centuries since the actual war! In reality, it was the Protestant Dutch provinces that rejected the strict Catholicism of Philip II, who, unlike Charles V, had been educated in Spain, and it was over this issue that the Eighty Years’ War was fought. The Belgians, particularly the French-speaking Walloons, remained subjects of the Spanish crown until 1713.

In the post-war period, relations between the two countries once again became significant, again for reasons linked to labour requirements, particularly in the coal-mining region. And, as with so many Mediterranean communities in Northern Europe, the Spanish victory has always been seen as a kind of compensation – intangible yet substantial – for the many injustices and humiliations endured in everyday life.

It is hard to imagine any serious tensions arising between the English and the Norwegians over a football, given how level-headed these peoples are – at least when they are sober. What’s more, the histories of the two countries are intertwined, whether it be the Viking invasions, the linguistic influence of Old Norse, or the accession to the throne in 1905 of Haakon VII, who was related to the British royal family.

But given that, if you dig a little deeper, you often find a few rifts even in the happiest of marriages – let alone in a bromance – London and Oslo also find themselves competing from time to time over North Sea oil. Thanks to greater public investment and other institutional factors, Norway is performing much better in terms of new discoveries. It’s unlikely that Kane and his team-mates are aware of this, and in any case, bringing the Cup back across the Channel after 60 years should be incentive enough, but when it comes to beating Haaland, everything counts… as fuel!

The final semi-finalist will emerge from the clash between the Albiceleste and the Nati, a fixture that would probably have piqued the interest of the ‘Maradona of literature’. Jorge Luís Borges certainly did not like sport, and even less so football, not least because he was almost blind. But he clearly recognised its power – albeit in a negative sense – as a vehicle for the worst of human tendencies, including nationalism.

And his bibliography certainly includes a story about football – or rather, about the world as seen through the lens of football. Written with his close friend Adolfo Bioy Casares, *Esse est percipi* (*To Be Is to Be Perceived*) is a critique of the mediatisation of reality, in which everyday actions are legitimised solely by the gaze of a third party. An observation that foreshadows the reality of social media, although Tuesday’s comeback, judging by the expressions on the Egyptian players’ faces, certainly had a lot of truth to it!

Borges spent various periods of his life in Switzerland, particularly in Geneva, where he is buried. He regarded it as the ideal city in which to discover the very essence of happiness. Would he have supported the Swiss national team back then? He certainly had great respect for brave and valiant men – and Lionel Messi, who isn’t afraid to miss yet another penalty just to keep the suspense going, certainly fits that description!

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti

Tutto mercato WEB