Oncology

Advanced breast cancer, liquid biopsy for evaluation of Esr1 mutations

An integrated approach to neoplasia with liquid biopsy can assure patients firstly thanks to a dedicated fund and then with the inclusion in the Essential Levels of Care of a correct diagnosis and appropriate therapy: the proposals of a Consensus with oncologists and anatomo-pathologists

by Umberto Malapelle *, Giuseppe Curigliano **, Carmine Pinto ***

4' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

4' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

The analysis of epidemiological data on advanced breast cancer (Cma) - 'locally advanced' (stage III) and 'metastatic' (stage IV) - shows that about 37.000 women live in Italy with this neoplasm in an aggressive form: the percentage of patients diagnosed with de novo metastatic disease is 6-7%, while it is estimated that 20-30% of tumour cases initially diagnosed at an early stage will undergo subsequent recurrence and systemic spread ("Linee guida Carcinoma Mammario Avanzato, 2023" Aiom).

With reference to the morphological classification of breast cancer lesions supplemented with the determination of the receptor profile of the neoplasm, HRpositive/HER2negative (HR+/HER2-) tumours are estimated in 70% of these patients.

Loading...

NGS Platforms and Esmo Recommendations

The spread of next-generation gene sequencing (NGS) platforms has contributed substantially to the development of new therapeutic pathways closely dependent on the spread of new biomarkers that play a key role in defining the choice of the most appropriate treatment in relation to the molecular aspects of the malignancy.

The 2024 recommendations of the European Society for Medical Oncology (Esmo), which regulate the use of NGS platforms in clinical practice, indicate as mandated the genotyping of the following biomarkers in HR+/HER2- CMA patients: PIK3CA and ESR1 mutations (estimated prevalence for both alterations 30-40%), PTEN and ATK1 mutations, with prevalence data in 7% and 5% of cases, respectively. Furthermore, germline BRCA 1-2 test profiling (4%), which plays a strategic role in both hereditary genetic risk management and familial prevention, should be performed in all metastatic patients who have not been evaluated in the early stages of disease.

Liquid biopsy and ESR1 activating mutations

This term commonly refers to the collection of peripheral venous blood to perform genomic characterisation analyses of neoplasia. In clinical practice, circulating tumour-derived nucleic acids (ctDNA) - which represent a small fraction (3x10-9 molecules/ml blood) of the free nucleic acids in the circulatory stream (cfDNA) released by physiological cell turnover processes - become the target of molecular investigation. The search for molecular alterations of clinical interest is carried out from cfDNA using highly sensitive technologies, such as digital PCR (dPCR) and NGS, which make it possible to detect any mutations present in the tumour fraction.

The diagnostic potential of liquid biopsy has found full application in the search for ESR1 (Estrogen Receptor 1) activating mutations: alterations in the gene coding for oestrogen receptor alpha (ERα), a key transcription factor in the regulation of the cell cycle and proliferation of oestrogen-sensitive cells. In particular, hotspot mutations in the gene are often associated with resistance to aromatase inhibitors.

The introduction of liquid biopsy into clinical practice for the profiling of ESR1 activating mutations (present in 30-40% of these patients) makes it possible to elect HR+/HER2- CMA patients for treatment with a new class of selective oral oestrogen receptor degraders (oral SERDs) after resistance to first-line treatment with aromatase inhibitors.

Profiling costs with liquid biopsy

On the subject of cost analysis of profiling in Precision Oncology, the Multidisciplinary Innovativeness Group has acquired specific know-how that has enabled it to define the cost of NGS profiling in the amount of euro 1,150, transposed in the MinSal Ministerial Decree 30.09.22 for Lung Adenocarcinoma and in the MinSal Ministerial Decree 06.03.23 for Cholangiocarcinoma (Pinto C. et al, GMI Health Economics 2021).

Using the same methodology, the overall cost of profiling with liquid biopsy of ESR1 activating mutations - by means of dPCR and NGS platforms at the Pathology Anatomy laboratories belonging to the facilities of the Consensus participants - was estimated, which includes: (i) costs of diagnostic activity (personnel for the time dedicated, consumables used, purchase or rental and maintenance of the platforms); (ii) structure costs, with a 20% increase in diagnostic costs (according to values reported in the scientific literature).

The economic analysis estimated an overall cost for the evaluation with liquid biopsy:

- of ESR1 activating mutations alone amounting to 450 euro by dPCR method

- of ESR1-activating mutations, plus PIK3CA, PTEN and ATK1 with an NGS platform of EUR 1,350 (as part of an integrated approach to metastatic disease, in order to cover all clinically relevant mutations in all genes covered by this analysis)

The Consensus and the economic analysis on liquid biopsy profiling (correlated with the real absorption of resources) highlighted the importance of an integrated approach to HR+/HER2- advanced breast cancer in order to ensure cancer patients - first with a dedicated fund and then with inclusion in the Lea - a correct diagnosis and subsequent treatment with appropriate therapy.

* Associate Professor, Department of Public Health - Federico II University - Naples; President of the International Society of Liquid Biopsy (ISLB)

** Director of New Drug Development Division - European Institute of Oncology, Irccs - Milan; Full Professor, Department of Oncology and Haemato-Oncology, University of Milan La Statale

*** Head Medical Oncology - Clinical Cancer Centre, Irccs - Ausl Reggio Emilia; Consensus Coordinator and Scientific Referent Multidisciplinary Innovativeness Group

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti