The Antalya Summit

COP31: reference to phasing out oil, gas and coal omitted

The phase-out of fossil fuels has been removed from the second draft of the framework decision. Electricity is set to account for 35 per cent of total energy consumption by 2035, but there is no mention of renewables

Un attivista chiede  l’aumento dei finanziamenti per il clima durante la Cop31) ad Antalya, in Turchia  (REUTERS) REUTERS

5' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

5' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

ANTALYA (TURKEY) – Any reference to oil, coal and gas is purely coincidental: the word ‘fossil’ has been removed from the text of the framework decision at COP31, currently taking place in Antalya. On Thursday 19 November, the presidency presented a second draft, scrapping most of the points contained in the first proposal, which was, in truth, an unrealistic wish list.

The ‘dinosaurs’ live amongst us

Fossil fuels are the main cause of global warming, ‘dinosaurs that must disappear’, as the United Nations Secretary-General, Antio Guterres, puts it. The Hormuz crisis has demonstrated once again, particularly to Europe, just how strategically risky such a dependence is, as it leaves us exposed to uncontrollable external shocks.

Loading...

At COP28 in Dubai, a commitment to a ‘transition away’ from oil, gas and coal had been successfully included in the cover decision. This wording was so ambiguous that, three years on, there is still debate over what it means, yet it has been omitted from the Antalya document. Of course, in the real world, renewables are growing, but not fast enough.

The Front Line

The new draft, halved to nine pages compared with the version presented on Monday 16th, is still considered ambitious, but it is not final. The conference in Turkey opened on 9 November and is scheduled to close on Friday 20. Negotiations are ongoing, and further changes are expected, most likely to water down, rather than strengthen, commitments to tackling climate change.

As always, the oil-producing states, led by Saudi Arabia – which opposes practically everything – are working against the transition, alongside Russia and India. China is also on this side of the fence, though it is proceeding more cautiously. The world’s second-largest economy ranks first in terms of greenhouse gas emissions, but also in terms of investment in renewables. It is undertaking its energy transition, but on its own terms and with a focus on power: to free itself from dependence on imported energy and to dominate green technology.

On the other side, the European Union and the Pacific island states – the latter of which are physically threatened by rising sea levels – are calling for more decisive action on cutting greenhouse gas emissions.

Panama, which has denounced the ‘oil mafia’, has sent an unusual letter to the COP presidency to announce that it will block any outcome that includes the introduction of a cap on global crude oil production.

The EU delegation, amongst other things, opposed the reference to CO₂ capture and storage, which nevertheless appears in the text. This is the solution that has always been proposed by oil producers and the fossil fuel lobbies (and which is popular in Italia).

Another sticking point for the EU is the reference to ‘unilateral trade measures’, as the CBAM is regarded as being outside the Union. The carbon border adjustment mechanism is intended to offset the competitive disadvantage faced by energy-intensive European companies, which are required to purchase CO₂ emission allowances under the ETS. Developing countries regard the CBAM as a tariff.

Emerging economies are calling for a threefold increase in funding for adaptation, which is mentioned in the text but with unclear implementation arrangements, as stated by Sandra Guzman, director of the Climate Finance Group for Latin America and the Caribbean. According to the United Nations Environment Programme, it is estimated that by 2035, developing countries will need around $305 billion a year for adaptation measures.

Loading...

The measure of success

Some negotiators believe that the summit’s success should not be judged by the words missing from the framework decision, which, for example, makes no reference whatsoever to clean energy sources in its call to increase the share of electricity in overall energy consumption to 35 per cent by 2035, from the current 23 per cent.

COP31 must be viewed in the context of the current situation. In Donald Trump’s fragmented world, where international law counts for only so much, multilateralism is in deep crisis. The World Trade Organisation (WTO), once the arbiter of disputes over tariffs and subsidies, has been reduced to an oversized think tank (through no fault of its institutional representatives or technical staff). The International Criminal Court is under attack, its judges subject to sanctions. The fact that a forum for global dialogue has managed to survive, that the process has been preserved, is not an achievement to be dismissed out of hand. Even if the United States has pulled out and is working against it. Even if the climate crisis would require much more. ‘Without the COPs, what would we be left with?’, many in Antalya are asking themselves.

And, after all, the conference in Turkey is an implementation conference – that is to say, one focused on putting commitments already made into practice. The expectation that new references to fossil fuels will be introduced at every COP clashes with the need to find language acceptable to all and to strike a balance with adaptation support. Several delegates emphasise that, whilst ‘it is frustrating that greenhouse gas emissions are not falling quickly enough, the success of this conference will not depend on a single sentence contained in the framework decision’.

‘People always expect more ambitious targets on fossil fuels to be introduced at every COP, but they forget that there must always be a balance. When official development assistance is being cut and international funding for adaptation is dwindling, it is very difficult to call for more ambitious mitigation targets,” says Linda Kalcher, founder and director of the think tank Strategic Perspectives and a COP veteran. Of course, she adds, “it is truly frustrating that greenhouse gas emissions are not falling quickly enough”; however, “I don’t believe the success of this conference will depend on a single sentence in the framework decision. Success also depends on what happens on the ground.’ Namely, ‘the rapid progress in clean electrification and the reduction in oil and gas consumption that we are seeing around the world.’

The Battle Over Science

At the current rate, the world is heading for a rise in global temperatures of more than 2.5 degrees, far exceeding the safety thresholds set out in the Paris Agreement and by science – which is itself under attack.

Saudi Arabia, Russia, India, China and developing countries, such as Kenya, are opposing the publication of three key reports by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change and are blocking its budget. The draft framework decision defends the body, which employs hundreds of researchers from around the world, recognises that its assessment reports are ‘the most robust and comprehensive analysis of climate science’, and calls on the body to continue providing information that is crucial for policy-making, ‘including all three’ of the expected reports.

The draft also acknowledges the problem of exceeding the 1.5-degree threshold for the rise in global average temperatures. It may seem trivial, given that it is already happening, but it is not, because it highlights the need to take action to reverse the trend. Or at least to put the brakes on, given that every decimal point counts.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti