Health and the environment

The EU Court of Auditors on PFAS: ‘Monitoring is still insufficient’

Nor is the European Union’s legal framework suited to regulating them adequately

PORTO PROGETTO MARE VIVO RECUPERO   RIFIUTI, PLASTICA IMAGOECONOMICA

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

There are over 10,000 of them, and they are used in every sector of industry: from construction to healthcare, and from technology to cosmetics and clothing. They are PFAS,‘forever chemicals’, used for their water-, oil- and stain-repellent properties and for their durability. And according to the European Court of Auditors, which today, 18 November, presented the report ‘The EU’s approach to PFAS (“forever chemicals”)’, the EU’s legal framework is not fit for purpose when it comes to regulating them. Even the enforcement measures to ensure compliance with the legislation – continues the Court, which examined the period between January 2020 and March 2026 – are still far too inadequate.

Key European issues

The European Union was among the first jurisdictions to impose restrictions on harmful PFAS, but what is still lacking is comprehensive regulation of these substances. For most PFAS, in fact, complete data from toxicological and ecotoxicological tests are not available; such data are only required when the substance is produced or imported in quantities exceeding 1,000 tonnes per year. Furthermore, most PFAS are not registered because they are produced or imported in quantities of less than one metric tonne per year or in the form of polymers.

Loading...

Among the most commonly used polymers is polytetrafluoroethylene, or PTFE, which is widely used in non-stick frying pans and waterproof textiles.

Another critical issue with the EU system, the Court continues, is the ‘substance-by-substance’ approach. ‘When one type of PFAS was subject to restrictions,’ the report states, ‘it was quickly replaced by another with a similar molecular structure and properties’: this is the phenomenon of undesirable substitution. The EU’s timeframe for taking action is also under scrutiny: on average, it takes six years to assess the risks posed by a PFAS and around five years to impose restrictions on particularly harmful substances.

Checks and reference thresholds

A further vulnerability in the European system relates to inspections. According to the Court, one third of Member States did not carry out targeted checks on PFAS to verify compliance with the EU’s REACH and POPs regulations between 2020 and 2025. Since 2021, despite the publication of scientific evidence on the hazards of PFAS, no restriction procedures have been initiated. The two amended regulations – one on fire-fighting foams and the other on perfluorohexanoic acid (PFHxA) – concern procedures initiated before 2021. At least two Member States, Denmark and France, have introduced stricter restrictions without waiting for EU action.

As for the reference thresholds in drinking water, these were set out in a 2020 directive based on data from 2017. Although the limits have generally been met, they have not been revised in the light of new scientific evidence: of the 25 countries that responded to the questionnaire, eight have adopted additional national limits. Nor have the reference parameters for food, established on the basis of a 2020 opinion from the European Food Safety Authority, been updated in line with monitoring results. In the case of food, some Member States have not carried out any checks, and there is no regulation setting a minimum number of such checks.

Recommendations

One of the Court’s recommendations concerns the need for the European Commission to review the limits for foodstuffs by 2028 and to assess the adequacy of those for water. For next year, the Commission, together with the European Chemicals Agency, is also being asked to speed up decisions on the proposal for a universal restriction on PFAS put forward in 2023 by five countries.

Furthermore, by 2028, cooperation between the Commission and Member States will also be required to establish an effective system of controls. Finally, there is a deadline in 2029 for the simplification of procedures relating to legislation on chemical substances, in order to reduce the time taken to adopt regulatory measures against harmful PFAS.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti