Health

Family doctors in inland areas: a choice between depopulation, community and technology

In the outpatient clinics of inland areas of Italy and Europe, primary care medicine is becoming the last public service. Amid depopulation, lack of services and new technologies, doctors tell why working in the suburbs is not a mission, but a professional choice

by Davide Madeddu (Il Sole 24 Ore), Andrea Muñoz (El Confidencial, Spain) and Giota Tessi (Efsyn, Greece)

4' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

4' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

The other side of medicine can be seen far from the hospitals, in country villages or high mountains, where the outpatient clinic, very often and due to depopulation phenomena, becomes a kind of last garrison of the state. It is the general practitioners who make it work.

It is they, even in inland areas - which 'are more or less similar throughout Italia' - who provide health care to a population that, in most cases, is mainly over 60.

Loading...

Federico Contu, a general practitioner in Nuxis, a village of 1,400 inhabitants in Sulcis, Sardinia, practises his profession in the 'suburbs' by choice. 'In my case it was what I wanted to do,' he says, 'in the sense that I always thought I would like to work in a village because I realised that the clinical rhythms and context were more welcoming to me. Today, he explains, there is also a scientific debate as to what might drive doctors to take up posts away from the big centres.

Everything revolves around depopulation: with the exodus of inhabitants, services are reduced and life in the 'peripheries' - whether rural or mountainous - becomes more complicated. 'Sardinia has orographic characteristics that are not unique,' argues Contu, who is also regional president of the Fimmg. 'We talk about inland areas, which are not simply rural areas. If you look at the national picture you realise that a large part of Italia is an inland area'. This is where the 'frontier' doctors operate, an activity that 'is not a mission, but a life and professional choice'.

"Rural medicine is almost a sub-specialisation of family medicine," Contu continues. In the past, family medicine was more similar to what is practised in the villages today. In the cities it has changed profoundly, while in the small towns it has remained tied to a certain traditionality in the practice of the profession. Technology has also arrived here, albeit with difficulties mainly related to the quality of connections, but without erasing the link with the community. "In rural areas, the community context is more felt and stronger: there is a social fabric that allows you to get to know those living next door.

However, there is no shortage of difficulties. Far from the specialist centres 'there are many more margins of uncertainty, because access to diagnostics is more difficult and it is more complex to request consultations'. Technology comes to the rescue: 'Having fewer possibilities to hook up second-level examinations, we make a virtue of necessity and try to compensate with the means available, such as telemedicine and remote diagnostics'. In some regions, such as Emilia-Romagna, consultations with specialists can take place in real time; in Sardinia, on the other hand, 'we are far behind on this front'.

The day does not end when the door of the surgery closes at 8pm. The paperwork and the mental workload remain. 'But don't call it a mission,' Contu concludes, 'this narrative is no longer correct. Better to call it a life and professional choice.

A look across the border

The community dimension also emerges strongly in Spain. Antonio García Navas, 57, a family doctor and representative of primary care physicians at the College of Physicians of Cadiz, has worked in both urban and rural areas. After an initial experience in the city, he chose rural medicine in the early 2000s, attracted by greater work continuity. Today, he works in Paterna de Rivera, a municipality of just over 5,500 inhabitants, about 40 minutes' drive from Cadiz.

"The big difference between urban and rural medicine," he explains, "is the community component. In rural areas the longitudinality of care increases: patients are followed over time, more home visits are made and many emergencies are managed directly. The social determinants of health, from the loneliness of the elderly to youth unemployment, also become more evident.

In the centre where García Navas works, three doctors work, with morning and afternoon shifts, nights on the premises and one weekend per month. Rural paediatrics is one of the critical nodes: "Many paediatricians do not want to work for long in isolated settings. Here, too, technology is changing the work: teleconsultations and ultrasound scanners in peripheral centres allow previously unthinkable diagnoses. And despite everything, 'professional satisfaction is often higher than in urban medicine'.

The theme of the periphery also runs through training. Carmen S. Bueno, radiologist, left Malaga to do her specialisation in Don Benito, Extremadura. "I knew that to choose the speciality I wanted I would have to leave. An experience initially lived with ambivalence, but which contributed to her professional and personal growth. Like many other residents, however, she always considered this phase as temporary, with the aim of returning to her home town.

Distance takes on an even different dimension in the Greek islands. In Kardamyla, a village on the island of Chios, being 'the teacher' or 'the doctor' often means losing one's name and being identified only with one's role. Community respect coexists with an emotional distance: one is perceived as a temporary figure, destined to leave. The departure of the last means of transport of the day - bus or ferry - marks the moment when isolation becomes tangible.

A feeling also shared by many doctors. "In a small town you live in a glass house," says a doctor who prefers to remain anonymous. "Everyone recognises you, but no one really knows you." When you close the front door, the contrast is stark: from the adrenalin rush of the clinic to the absolute quiet of the village. Even the digital connection only partially helps: 'Sometimes it amplifies the distance and makes you feel like a spectator of your own life'.

*This article is part of the European collaborative journalism project "Pulse"

Copyright reserved ©

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti