Court of Cassation

Misuse of permits under Law 104: telephone records are also to be examined

The judge cannot dismiss them without giving reasons and may not rely solely on other evidence

Credits: Pixabay (Pexels)

2' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

2' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

In the case concerning the dismissal for misuse of the leave entitlements provided for under Law 104/1992, telephone records that contradict the employee’s account cannot be deemed irrelevant without an explanation. The judge must examine that evidence; otherwise, the reasoning is superficial and the judgement is null and void. This is confirmed by the Court of Cassation in Order 29047/2026.

The story

The case giving rise to the ruling concerns a supermarket employee who was dismissed for just cause on 29 February 2024 for alleged abuse of three periods of leave intended for the care of her disabled mother. The employee claimed that she had visited her parents at night, accompanied on some occasions by friends, after being informed by her father that assistance was required. The company commissioned a private investigation agency to verify her movements; telephone records were also obtained during the proceedings.

Loading...

Judgements at first and second instance

The Court dismissed the appeal against the dismissal, noting inconsistencies in the employee’s account. The Perugia Court of Appeal overturned the decision: on the basis of the testimonies of her friends and the employee’s own statements, it considered it proventhat night-time care had taken place. Having established that the alleged offence did not take place, it ordered the employee’s reinstatement and the payment of compensation and social security contributions as provided for in Article 18, paragraph 4, of the Workers’ Statute.

The crucial point concerns the father’s phone calls which, according to the employee herself, had led to the night-time interventions on 15 and 31 January 2024. The call records, however, had shown the absence of telephone contact with her parents on 14, 30 and 31 January. The Court attached significance to this fact: without the phone call, the premise of the reconstruction was refuted, including the subsequent request via Telegram for a friend to accompany her.

The Court of Appeal referred to the call records, stating only that they did not add any evidence to the case.

Relevant telephone number

In the Court of Cassation’s view, this is merely a superficial justification. The judges should have explained why the testimonies regarding the night-time accompaniment were sufficient to prove that assistance had been provided, despite the absence of the very phone calls cited by the employee as the reason for the interventions. The telephone records should have been examined to reconstruct the circumstances that had led the worker to her parents’ home.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti