Constitutional Court

‘Prisons: urgent measures to tackle overcrowding’

The question of constitutionality raised by the Court of Florence has been ruled inadmissible. The Constitutional Court calls for the expansion of alternative measures


ANSA/CLAUDIO GIOVANNINI ANSA

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

It has ruled that the question of constitutional legitimacy raised by the Florence Supervisory Court is inadmissible, but has urged the legislature to take ‘essential and urgent measures’ to alleviate – safely – prison overcrowding. For example, through “the expansion of alternative measures”.

Judgment 206/2026

The Constitutional Court has once again ruled on the prison system. And it has done so on the basis of a cell at the Sollicciano – a prison with severe water seepage, no hot water and bedbugs in the beds. The application sought to grant the supervisory court the power to postpone the enforcement of the sentence or to convert it to house arrest, in light of conditions contrary to human dignity. In Judgment 206/2024, the Constitutional Court (rapporteur Francesco Viganò, future president) ruled that the question of constitutionality was inadmissible because the Supervisory Court, before raising it, ‘should have utilised all the powers conferred by law to put an end to the infringement of the convicted person’s rights’.

Loading...

Legal remedies

In essence, domestic remedies do exist; they are provided for, in particular, by Article 35-bis of the Prison Act, but the Florentine judiciary – according to the Court – has not demonstrated that it has utilised the full range of such remedies. This range includes, in addition to the possibility of transfer the prisoner, also the appointment of a commissioner capable of taking the place of the prison administration.

A complaint has been received from a prisoner sentenced to 22 years for murder – one of 446 submitted between 2023 and 2026 by Sollicciano – the Supervision Court had ordered the prison administration to carry out work on the building and facilities. It had set a deadline and, in the face of substantial non-compliance, had raised the question of constitutional legitimacy.

Sollicciano: infiltrazioni, cimici e qualche “panneggio d’amore”

Sollicciano: between seizures and interventions

In the meantime, however, seven wings have been sealed off at the request of the Florence Public Prosecutor’s Office; the prisoner has been transferred, along with others, to a different prison; and work has been carried out to restore the water supply and tackle pest infestations. The State Legal Service also refers to the plans of the Special Commissioner for Prison Construction and the measure to place 8,173 prisoners with addictions. Thus, ‘precisely because of the variety of possible solutions’, starting with the transfer of the prisoner, the Constitutional Court has declared the question of constitutionality inadmissible, much to the disappointment of the criminal law associations, which have described it as a ‘sad day’.

The ultimate remedy

The judges point out, however, that the ‘last resort’, involving ‘the prisoner’s removal from the prison system’, remains a possibility ‘whenever “internal” remedies prove ineffective’. And ‘where the legislature fails to provide for this’, they write, ‘this Court will certainly be entitled to intervene’.

Overcrowding

On the other hand, with overcrowding having reached the same levels as those cited in the 2013 ECHR judgement, the situation risks becoming ‘increasingly problematic’, warns the Constitutional Court - to ensure the necessary protection of the right of individual prisoners not to be subjected to detention inhuman and degrading treatment”. A right that constitutes ‘a defining feature of a legal system founded on respect for the dignity of every person’, to be guaranteed not only to those who lodge complaints, but to all prisoners, including the very many foreign nationals who face greater difficulties in accessing legal assistance. Hence the call from the constitutional judges for ‘urgent and essential measures’: pending the announced prison reform plan, ‘the revision or broadening of the criteria for access to alternative measures’, as called for as long as 13 years ago.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti