Pulse

Education and integration, from Italia to Sweden: how Europe is tackling the challenge of foreign students

From the ‘roof’ scheme for international students proposed by the Meloni government to Germany’s language classes, right through to the models adopted in France, Spain and the Nordic countries: here’s how European education systems are tackling the challenge of integrating pupils from migrant backgrounds

by Silvia Martelli (Il Sole 24 Ore, Italia), Francesca Barca (Voxeurop, France), Karolina Słowik (Gazeta Wyborcza, Poland) and Petr Jedlička (Deník Referendum, Czech Republic)

Aggiungi Il Sole 24 Ore
ai preferiti su Google

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

From preparatory classes for new arrivals in Germany and Sweden to France’s strict principles of secularism, via the language programmes introduced in Poland following the arrival of hundreds of thousands of Ukrainian refugees. Across Europe, governments and education systems are seeking to answer the same question: how to integrate a growing number of pupils from different linguistic and cultural backgrounds without creating segregation or compromising learning.

It is in this context that

The proposal comes at a time when pupils who are not Italian nationals account for around 11.6 per cent of the national school-age population – according to data compiled by the ISMU Foundation based on ISTAT figures for the 2024/2025 school year – and brings back to the forefront of the debate an issue that affects much of the continent: striking a balance between linguistic integration, social inclusion and the cohesion of school communities.

The idea of setting a maximum quota for foreign pupils is not entirely new. In Italia, a ministerial circular has been in place for years, setting a target limit of 30 per cent of pupils with non-Italian citizenship per class, but the measure has largely gone unenforced in areas with a high migrant population. The president of the National Association of Headteachers himself, Antonello Giannelli, has described the proposal as ‘reasonable’ from an educational point of view but difficult to implement in practice, particularly in schools in neighbourhoods where the foreign population is particularly large.

In France, there are no quotas or caps on the number of foreign students. The right to education is guaranteed to all children, regardless of their nationality or knowledge of French. Newly arrived students are enrolled in the EANA programme, which provides intensive language support with the aim of integrating them quickly into mainstream classes.

The debate in France centres primarily on the principle of laïcité, one of the pillars of the republican system. Since 2004, a law has prohibited the wearing of religious symbols considered ‘ostentatious’ in state schools, including the Islamic headscarf, the kippah and large crosses, whilst allowing discreet religious symbols. The stated aim is to ensure the neutrality of the school environment and to preserve equality amongst pupils.

Germany does not impose national limits on the number of foreign pupils in classes. The emphasis is instead on rapid language acquisition. In many Länder, newly arrived pupils attend preparatory classes (‘Deutschklassen’) for one or two years, where they receive intensive German language tuition, before being fully integrated into mainstream education. In Bavaria, for example, there are specific programmes that combine additional language courses with classes dedicated to new arrivals. Cities such as Stuttgart have also developed school orientation systems that assess language skills and individual needs before pupils are placed in mainstream classes.

Spain does not impose national quotas on foreign students. In recent years, the debate has focused primarily on the distribution of pupils between state schools and ‘concertadas’ (private schools largely funded by public money) and on the need to avoid excessive concentrations in certain schools. The autonomous communities run language integration and support programmes for recently arrived students, with a particular focus on areas experiencing the highest levels of migration.

In Poland, there are no numerical limits or restrictions on religious dress. Since 2022, the education system has taken in hundreds of thousands of pupils from Ukraine. Today, around 332,000 foreign nationals attend Polish schools and educational institutions, and over 86 per cent of them come from Ukraine.

The main problem is not the distribution of pupils across classes, but the quality of linguistic and educational integration: experts and teachers highlight the lack of preparatory classes and dedicated Polish language courses.