Marketing

The darker side of supply chains and risks to brand value

The focus on new multilateral alliances of companies is becoming increasingly central. The dangers are also increasing, making internal confrontation and supply chain control indispensable

by Giampaolo Colletti and Fabio Grattagliano

4' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

4' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

Distinguishing marks: concentrated. It can't be any other way when a tomato is competing in the Olympics of quality. This is the new campaign of Heinz, a company founded in 1869 in Pennsylvania by Henry J. Heinz, a young entrepreneur and son of German immigrants. The claim links the athletes' determination with the brand's commitment to ingredient selection. A declaration of intent towards the supply chain of the American giant of over 25 billion dollars with 36 thousand employees worldwide and a global market of 40 countries. Thus dozens of tomatoes are transformed into as many athletes in their green crown that surmounts each product. The leaves are folded, shaped and oriented as if they were the disciplines of the China National Games.

 The nodes of the extended brand

Tell me who you're with and I'll tell you who you are: a warning that becomes central in times marked by the relevance of reputational capital, which is transformed - when correctly valorised and strategically reinforced - into economic capital. Hence the focus on new multilateral brand alliances. Because in order to win the commercial challenge it is necessary to considerthe extended supply chain in its plurality. Each brand can be a partner of several others and relationships can have shared nodes. Thus also the supply chain with third parties becomes circular and continuous, and always potentially at risk.

Loading...

"Right now, marketing, which used to have a certain autonomy, cannot work unless it is perfectly in tune with everything else. The supply chain used to be delegated to the purchasing part, but today it affects everything and these silos breaks presuppose new competences. You have to be able to dialogue with others in a sort of multidisciplinary way,' says Carlo Alberto Pratesi, professor of marketing at Roma Tre University.

On the other hand, never before have the big giants been in communication check because of their relationships with third parties. This is highlighted by new American research in theJournal of Business Research: more alliances increase the overall share. "The contemporary consumer has become activist, ready to reward or punish brands based also on the behaviour of third parties. Today, they read ingredients, study them, they are also informed from a values point of view. In short, he wants to know upstream who made the product. This sensitivity is not necessarily high-spending, but certainly more sensitive,' Pratesi points out.

 The Supply Chain Trap

In the global geopolitical game when not properly manned, the extended supply chain becomes a trap. Invisible until everything goes smoothly, cumbersome when something goes wrong. In the economy of interdependencies, reputation becomes thin, permeable, vulnerable to mistakes. In recent months, the business world has offered a sharp sampling of this domino effect. In our country, prosecutors have accelerated their investigations on alleged abuses in several fashion companies, exposing them to potential image damage and jeopardising the economy of the entire industry. But the phenomenon is global and picking up speed in other sectors as well.

There is the technology front, with Apple being sued by a US NGO for the indirect use of minerals mined in Congo under conditions of child or forced labour. The Cupertino giant is not accused of breaking the law, but of not having sufficiently controlled a long and opaque supply chain from artisanal miners to Asian smelters. Also in the United States, an investigation by the Bureau of investigative journalism links brands such as Vans, The North Face, Timberland, and Nike to suppliers involved in "relocated worker" programmes from western China. Bumble Bee Foods is accused of being an indirect beneficiary of forced labour on Asian fishing vessels. This is the dark side of the globalisation of canned tuna: long supply chains, fragile controls, stories of exploitation that become hashtags and then news, often before the facts are established.

In the meantime, the finger is also pointed at large retailers: Walmart, Costco, Kroger, Whole Foods, Amazon Fresh are cited as reputational risks for not being able to guarantee decent conditions in thesupply chains of fish and shellfish halfway around the world. Then there is the fast fashion jungle. Shein has just been recalled by the OECD for lack of transparency on the supply chain and possible connection to forced labour in Xinjiang. Meanwhile in Australia Kmart ends up in court because a Uyghur association demands clarity on textile suppliers.

The spillover effect

The bad publicity of a supplier generates a direct economic impact on the performance of the parent company. This is the spillover effect, the snowball effect as described in research published in the International journal of production economics by scholars Li Wang, Yuxiao Ye and Baofeng Huo. Their work has a title that is already a warning: 'Spillover of bad publicity'. Translated: bad publicity runs, infects, overwhelms. And every brand is only as good as its most fragile link.

"Today, the company cannot limit itself to its core business: it has to oversee the entire ecosystem of partners, suppliers and collaborators. The benefit of a clean supply chain is not always immediate: it often requires investments in compliance, auditing, resources, which can affect operating costs in the short term," says Pratesi.

So how does one combine the urgency of continuous innovation with the presidium on extended brand relationships? For Pratesi, care must be taken to synthesise with consistency. In short, less is more. "The tendency is to add, but conscious decisions have to be made. In this sense family businesses are at an advantage because they are capable of a long-term vision, beyond mere immediate economic and financial benefits'.

Copyright reserved ©
Loading...

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti