Constitutional Court

Civil partnerships: the legislature should consider the issue of international adoption of children

According to the Constitutional Court, it is Parliament’s responsibility to assess whether same-sex couples should be granted access. However, the ban on adoption by adults is unconstitutional

(Photo by GABRIEL BOUYS / AFP) AFP

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

3' min read

Translated by AI
Versione italiana

It is not for the Constitutional Court ‘in the process of the gradual evolution of family law , to weigh up the impact of social changes that have taken place on the assessment of the best interests of an abandoned child, nor to carry out any systemic interventions’. However, it is the task of the legislature to assess whether civilly partnered couples may be eligible for the international adoption of foreign children.

This was stated by the Constitutional Court in judgement number 194, filed today, which declared inadmissible the questions regarding the constitutionality of Article 29-bis of Law 184/1983, insofar as it does not include civilly partnered couples amongst those eligible to submit a declaration of willingness to adopt a foreign child.

Loading...

Safeguarding the best interests

According to the legal expert, in the regulations regulating access to international adoption, the legislator is required to identify the characteristics of the family that must fulfil the best interests of the abandoned child. The Court’s standard of assessment is less stringent than in cases where adoption serves to recognise a relationship already established with the child, which is reflected in the child’s identity.

The Court emphasises, however, that it cannot ‘overlook the fact that many legal – and not merely social – changes have affected many of the assumptions underlying the balancing of interests carried out by the legislature’, which will be required to address these developments. In particular, in light of the recognition of parent-child relationships with intended parents in same-sex couples, the Constitutional Court states that ‘the legislature may well consider the willingness of same-sex couples in civil partnerships to undergo a suitability assessment in practice to adopt an abandoned child, in a spirit of solidarity and in accordance with Article 2 of the Constitution’.

Legal and social changes

‘Ultimately, it will be up to the legislator to carry out an assessment of the child’s best interests, within the context of a legal system that has undergone profound change, and to implement, in accordance with constitutional provisions, possible reforms to the system capable of taking account of the many variables that have changed and of reorganising the various aspects of the legislation, so that the cornerstone of the adoption legislation remains the rights of the child to have a family, capable of providing them with care, love, stability and protection, and of enabling them to overcome the traumas of the past’, concludes the Constitutional Court.

Adoption of an adult

In contrast, today’s decision (judgement 195) – also handed down today – saw the Constitutional Court rule that the ban on a civilly partnered couple adopting aperson of legal age. The Court has declared the second paragraph of Article 294 of the Civil Code to be unconstitutional, insofar as it does not provide that members of a civil partnership may also adopt the same person. This prohibition unreasonably and disproportionately infringes upon the identity of both the adoptee and the adopters.

The adoption of an adult, the Court explains, makes it possible to grant legal recognition to an emotional relationship ‘which, by virtue of its nature, intensity and reasonable duration’, has ‘the potential to influence the identity of the adoptee and the adopters’. The Constitutional Court recognises that the prohibition on being adopted by more than one person, unless they are spouses, serves the need to avoid the proliferation of adoptive parent-child relationships with people who are strangers to one another. However, it considers that, in order to safeguard this requirement, it is not necessary to compel those who have established a personal relationship with both members of a civil partnership to choose to be adopted by only one of the two.

The family-oriented nature of civil partnerships

According to the Court, an examination of Law No. 76/2016 shows that a civil partnership constitutes a status that has ‘a family-like nature’ and to which ‘a single status as an adopted child may well be associated’. Although the law itself had excluded parent-child relationships in the context of civil partnerships, subsequent developments in the legal system, with the recognition of parent-child relationships with the intended parent of a same-sex couple, has made it legally untenable to consider a civil partnership and the establishment of a parent-child relationship to be incompatible.

Consequently, the extension of the prohibition laid down in Article 294 of the Civil Code to civilly partnered couples is disproportionate, since the purpose of the provision can be achieved by recognising that a single status as a couple corresponds to a single status as an adopted child.

‘Ultimately, where all prospective adoptive parents have given their consent, and the approvals required by law have been obtained, there are no conflicting interests which, in a balancing exercise, would stand in the way of the protection of personal identity; this highlights the unreasonable and disproportionate infringement to which it is subjected”, concludes the Constitutional Court.

Copyright reserved ©

Brand connect

Loading...

Newsletter

Notizie e approfondimenti sugli avvenimenti politici, economici e finanziari.

Iscriviti